{"schemaVersion":1,"seed":2612004,"caseCount":600,"startedAt":"2026-10-25T10:29:26.582Z","completedAt":"2026-10-25T10:34:27.918Z","models":["jev-1.14.0"],"questionVersion":"facts-v1","thresholds":{"approve":0.9,"deny":0.98},"source":"600 real Jev assessments of synthetic cases","summary":{"approve":91,"deny":200,"review":309,"automation":0.485,"unlabeled":175,"labeledAutomated":291,"disagreements":0,"modeledLoss":7725},"records":[{"case":{"id":"EE-0001","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.83,"clarityScore":0.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.82,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:29:26.582Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.18,0.82,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.82,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"8 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"82% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0002","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.73,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.71,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:00.419Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.05,0.16,0.78],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":416,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0003","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.68,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.68,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:00.784Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.32,0.68,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":93,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0004","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.27,"clarityScore":0.11,"evidenceConfidence":0.74,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:01.024Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.74,0.26,0,0],"clarity":[0.9,0.1,0,0]}},"durationMs":88,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":300,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €600; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €300.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0005","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.81,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.81,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:01.272Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.19,0.81,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":93,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0006","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.43,"clarityScore":2.36,"evidenceConfidence":0.51,"clarityConfidence":0.52,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:01.515Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.52,0.44,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.06,0.52,0.42]}},"durationMs":90,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.51,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"0 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"51% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.4/3, clarity 2.4/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0007","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.71,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.7,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:01.781Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.05,0.17,0.77],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":112,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.7,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"8 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"96% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"70% conservative judgment strength; 98% denial threshold. Evidence 2.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 98%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0008","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.95,"clarityScore":2.91,"evidenceConfidence":0.47,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:02.033Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.21,0.51,0.24],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.08,0.91]}},"durationMs":101,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"179 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 179 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0009","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.48,"evidenceScore":1.09,"clarityScore":1.58,"evidenceConfidence":0.91,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:02.267Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.93,0.05,0.02],"clarity":[0.41,0.01,0.16,0.42]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0010","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.94,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.94,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:02.527Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.94,0,0],"clarity":[1,0,0,0]}},"durationMs":109,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.94,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"181 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"94% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.9/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0011","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.67,"evidenceScore":2.42,"clarityScore":2.71,"evidenceConfidence":0.42,"clarityConfidence":0.72,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:02.762Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.18,0.19,0.62],"clarity":[0.08,0.01,0.02,0.89]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0012","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"crew","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.22,"clarityScore":2.67,"evidenceConfidence":0.56,"clarityConfidence":0.66,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:02.993Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.11,0.57,0.31,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.32,0.67]}},"durationMs":143,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":200,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €200.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0013","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.2,"clarityScore":0.11,"evidenceConfidence":0.8,"clarityConfidence":0.89,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:03.318Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.8,0.2,0,0],"clarity":[0.89,0.11,0,0]}},"durationMs":107,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0014","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.21,"clarityScore":0.09,"evidenceConfidence":0.8,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:03.554Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.8,0.2,0,0],"clarity":[0.91,0.09,0,0]}},"durationMs":84,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":250,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €250.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0015","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.81,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.8,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:03.805Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.2,0.8,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":99,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0016","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.82,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.33,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:04.065Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.09,0.24,0.42,0.25],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":103,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0017","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.27,"clarityScore":0.11,"evidenceConfidence":0.74,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:04.301Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.74,0.26,0,0],"clarity":[0.9,0.1,0,0]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":250,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €250.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0018","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.96,"clarityScore":2.93,"evidenceConfidence":0.41,"clarityConfidence":0.93,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:04.531Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.22,0.45999999999999996,0.27],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.05,0.94]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.41,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"181 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"41% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 2.0/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0019","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.37,"clarityScore":0.19,"evidenceConfidence":0.63,"clarityConfidence":0.82,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:04.763Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.63,0.37,0,0],"clarity":[0.8200000000000001,0.18,0,0]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0020","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"crew","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1,"clarityScore":1.05,"evidenceConfidence":0.96,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:05.028Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.02,0.96,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.56,0.02,0.21,0.2]}},"durationMs":112,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"180 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"0% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.0/3, clarity 1.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0021","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.9,"clarityScore":2.87,"evidenceConfidence":0.42,"clarityConfidence":0.89,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:05.265Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.24,0.47,0.24],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.09,0.9]}},"durationMs":84,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0.42,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"13.9 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"42% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.9/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0022","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.77,"clarityScore":2.99,"evidenceConfidence":0.34,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:05.529Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.08,0.28,0.42,0.22],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":103,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.34,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"13.9 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"34% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.8/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0023","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.78,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.78,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:05.835Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.22,0.78,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":157,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0024","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.93,"clarityScore":0,"evidenceConfidence":0.93,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:06.118Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.07,0.93,0,0],"clarity":[1,0,0,0]}},"durationMs":126,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.93,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"0 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"93% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.9/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0025","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.72,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.72,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:06.350Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.05,0.15,0.79],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.72,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"241 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"96% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"72% conservative judgment strength; 98% denial threshold. Evidence 2.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 98%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0026","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.93,"clarityScore":2.83,"evidenceConfidence":0.47,"clarityConfidence":0.84,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:06.592Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.23,0.51,0.22],"clarity":[0.01,0.02,0.09,0.88]}},"durationMs":89,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":300,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €600; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €300.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0027","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":2.04,"clarityScore":2.92,"evidenceConfidence":0.46,"clarityConfidence":0.92,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:06.857Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.19,0.49,0.29],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.06,0.93]}},"durationMs":115,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"179 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 179 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0028","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"crew","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.98,"clarityScore":1.05,"evidenceConfidence":0.94,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:07.093Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.94,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.57,0.02,0.21,0.2]}},"durationMs":83,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0029","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"crew","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.99,"clarityScore":1.13,"evidenceConfidence":0.95,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:07.331Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.95,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.54,0.02,0.22,0.22]}},"durationMs":85,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0030","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"weather","evidence":"partial","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.43,"evidenceScore":1.98,"clarityScore":2.91,"evidenceConfidence":0.7,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:07.593Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.16,0.7,0.14],"clarity":[0,0,0.09,0.91]}},"durationMs":109,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0031","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.49,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.28,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:07.827Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.11,0.41,0.35,0.13],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0032","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.44,"clarityScore":2.34,"evidenceConfidence":0.48,"clarityConfidence":0.54,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:08.084Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.49,0.46,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.06,0.54,0.4]}},"durationMs":107,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.48,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"0 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"48% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.4/3, clarity 2.3/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0033","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.26,"evidenceScore":1.14,"clarityScore":1.33,"evidenceConfidence":0.85,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:08.319Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.89,0.07,0.04],"clarity":[0.52,0.01,0.11,0.36]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0034","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.97,"evidenceScore":2.73,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.74,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:08.550Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.05,0.16,0.79],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.74,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"97% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"74% conservative judgment strength; 98% denial threshold. Evidence 2.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 98%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0035","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"crew","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.23,"clarityScore":2.7,"evidenceConfidence":0.58,"clarityConfidence":0.69,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:08.799Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.09,0.59,0.31,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.29,0.7]}},"durationMs":100,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0036","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.86,"clarityScore":0.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.86,"clarityConfidence":0.98,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:09.047Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.14,0.86,0,0],"clarity":[0.98,0.02,0,0]}},"durationMs":86,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0037","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"crew","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.01,"clarityScore":1.09,"evidenceConfidence":0.96,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:09.282Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.02,0.96,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.55,0.02,0.21,0.22]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0038","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.9,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.9,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:09.517Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.9,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.9,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"241 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"90% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.9/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0039","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.93,"clarityScore":0,"evidenceConfidence":0.93,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:09.813Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.07,0.93,0,0],"clarity":[1,0,0,0]}},"durationMs":138,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0040","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.66,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.27,"clarityConfidence":0.98,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:10.050Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.12,0.29,0.39,0.2],"clarity":[0,0,0.02,0.98]}},"durationMs":134,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0.27,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"0 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"27% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0041","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.88,"clarityScore":2.86,"evidenceConfidence":0.44,"clarityConfidence":0.86,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:10.353Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.24,0.49,0.22],"clarity":[0,0.02,0.1,0.88]}},"durationMs":97,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0042","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"crew","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1,"clarityScore":1.08,"evidenceConfidence":0.96,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:10.591Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.02,0.96,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.54,0.03,0.21,0.22]}},"durationMs":86,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"239 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"0% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.0/3, clarity 1.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0043","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"weather","evidence":"partial","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.42,"evidenceScore":2.01,"clarityScore":2.94,"evidenceConfidence":0.62,"clarityConfidence":0.94,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:10.839Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.18,0.62,0.2],"clarity":[0,0,0.06,0.94]}},"durationMs":95,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"119 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 119 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0044","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.9,"clarityScore":2.88,"evidenceConfidence":0.42,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:11.074Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.24,0.47,0.24],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.08,0.91]}},"durationMs":84,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.42,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"42% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.9/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0045","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.48,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.28,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:11.313Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.12,0.4,0.36,0.12],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":85,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":250,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €250.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0046","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.83,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.83,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:11.571Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.17,0.83,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":98,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.83,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"239 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"83% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0047","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"crew","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.22,"clarityScore":2.65,"evidenceConfidence":0.59,"clarityConfidence":0.65,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:11.818Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.09,0.6,0.3,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.33,0.66]}},"durationMs":95,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":200,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €200.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0048","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"weather","evidence":"partial","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.49,"evidenceScore":2,"clarityScore":2.91,"evidenceConfidence":0.67,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:12.059Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.16,0.67,0.17],"clarity":[0,0,0.09,0.91]}},"durationMs":90,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0049","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.81,"clarityScore":2.79,"evidenceConfidence":0.4,"clarityConfidence":0.79,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:12.300Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.3,0.45,0.2],"clarity":[0.03,0.02,0.08,0.87]}},"durationMs":91,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":200,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €200.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0050","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.72,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.72,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:12.541Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.28,0.72,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":163,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.72,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"240 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"72% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.7/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0051","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.8,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.8,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:12.850Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.2,0.8,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0052","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.79,"clarityScore":0.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.79,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:13.085Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.21,0.79,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":600,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €600; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €600.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0053","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.06,"clarityScore":0.72,"evidenceConfidence":0.92,"clarityConfidence":0.29,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:13.321Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.9299999999999999,0.05,0.01],"clarity":[0.67,0.07,0.14,0.12]}},"durationMs":84,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0.29,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"360 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"29% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.1/3, clarity 0.7/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 240 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0054","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.83,"clarityScore":2.75,"evidenceConfidence":0.4,"clarityConfidence":0.74,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:13.555Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.29,0.45,0.21],"clarity":[0.04,0.03,0.08,0.85]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0055","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.66,"evidenceScore":2.47,"clarityScore":2.76,"evidenceConfidence":0.47,"clarityConfidence":0.75,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:13.786Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.15,0.2,0.64],"clarity":[0.07,0.01,0.02,0.9]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0056","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.97,"evidenceScore":2.72,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.7,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:14.034Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.05,0.17,0.77],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":96,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.7,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"0 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"97% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"70% conservative judgment strength; 98% denial threshold. Evidence 2.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 98%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0057","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.68,"evidenceScore":2.51,"clarityScore":2.79,"evidenceConfidence":0.52,"clarityConfidence":0.78,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:14.272Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.14,0.17,0.68],"clarity":[0.06,0.01,0.02,0.91]}},"durationMs":83,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":250,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €250.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0058","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.83,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.83,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:14.508Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.17,0.83,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":83,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.83,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"0 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"83% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0059","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.85,"clarityScore":2.88,"evidenceConfidence":0.44,"clarityConfidence":0.89,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:14.753Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.27,0.48,0.21],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.09,0.9]}},"durationMs":91,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0060","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.35,"clarityScore":0.16,"evidenceConfidence":0.65,"clarityConfidence":0.84,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:14.998Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.65,0.35,0,0],"clarity":[0.84,0.16,0,0]}},"durationMs":91,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.65,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6.9 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"65% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.3/3, clarity 0.2/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0061","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.26,"evidenceScore":1.11,"clarityScore":1.47,"evidenceConfidence":0.88,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:15.232Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.91,0.06,0.03],"clarity":[0.46,0.01,0.14,0.39]}},"durationMs":83,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0062","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"crew","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.23,"clarityScore":2.66,"evidenceConfidence":0.56,"clarityConfidence":0.66,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:15.473Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.57,0.32,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.32,0.67]}},"durationMs":89,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0063","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.88,"clarityScore":2.89,"evidenceConfidence":0.42,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:15.729Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.25,0.47,0.23],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.08,0.91]}},"durationMs":102,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.42,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"13 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"42% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.9/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0064","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.71,"evidenceScore":2.52,"clarityScore":2.77,"evidenceConfidence":0.52,"clarityConfidence":0.78,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:15.987Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.14,0.17,0.68],"clarity":[0.06,0.01,0.02,0.91]}},"durationMs":109,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":250,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €250.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0065","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.81,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.8,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:16.219Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.2,0.8,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":76,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"119 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 119 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0066","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.93,"clarityScore":0.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.93,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:16.451Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.07,0.93,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"119 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 119 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0067","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.48,"clarityScore":2.37,"evidenceConfidence":0.47,"clarityConfidence":0.54,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:16.720Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.48,0.48,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.04,0.54,0.42]}},"durationMs":116,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0068","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.77,"clarityScore":2.99,"evidenceConfidence":0.34,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:16.956Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.08,0.28,0.42,0.22],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0069","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.91,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.91,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:17.187Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.09,0.91,0,0],"clarity":[1,0,0,0]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0070","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"weather","evidence":"partial","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.39,"evidenceScore":2,"clarityScore":2.9,"evidenceConfidence":0.7,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:17.433Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.15,0.7,0.15],"clarity":[0,0,0.09,0.91]}},"durationMs":92,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.61,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"360 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"39% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"61% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 2.0/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 90%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0071","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.69,"evidenceScore":2.52,"clarityScore":2.81,"evidenceConfidence":0.52,"clarityConfidence":0.81,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:17.673Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.13,0.19,0.67],"clarity":[0.06,0,0.01,0.93]}},"durationMs":89,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0072","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.74,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.74,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:17.926Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.26,0.74,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":101,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.74,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6.9 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"74% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.7/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0073","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.24,"clarityScore":0.1,"evidenceConfidence":0.77,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:18.176Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.77,0.23,0,0],"clarity":[0.9,0.1,0,0]}},"durationMs":95,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0074","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.94,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.94,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:18.416Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.94,0,0],"clarity":[1,0,0,0]}},"durationMs":88,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0075","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.24,"clarityScore":0.09,"evidenceConfidence":0.77,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:18.646Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.77,0.23,0,0],"clarity":[0.91,0.09,0,0]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0076","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.97,"evidenceScore":2.73,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.72,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:18.894Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.05,0.15,0.79],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":96,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.72,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"8 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"97% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"72% conservative judgment strength; 98% denial threshold. Evidence 2.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 98%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0077","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.79,"clarityScore":2.88,"evidenceConfidence":0.38,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:19.128Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.07,0.28,0.45,0.2],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.08,0.91]}},"durationMs":89,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.38,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"38% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.8/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0078","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.71,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.3,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:19.373Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.29,0.4,0.21],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":83,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.3,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"0 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"30% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0079","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.57,"clarityScore":2.4,"evidenceConfidence":0.52,"clarityConfidence":0.53,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:19.620Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.02,0.42,0.54,0.02],"clarity":[0,0.04,0.53,0.43]}},"durationMs":94,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.52,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"240 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"52% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.6/3, clarity 2.4/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0080","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.81,"clarityScore":2.8,"evidenceConfidence":0.4,"clarityConfidence":0.79,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:19.880Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.29,0.45,0.21],"clarity":[0.03,0.02,0.08,0.87]}},"durationMs":108,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":250,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €250.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0081","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.72,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.72,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:20.119Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.28,0.72,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":87,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0.72,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"181 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"72% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.7/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 240 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0082","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.7,"clarityScore":2.79,"evidenceConfidence":0.4,"clarityConfidence":0.81,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:20.354Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.33,0.46,0.15],"clarity":[0.02,0.02,0.09,0.87]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0083","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.45,"clarityScore":2.3,"evidenceConfidence":0.48,"clarityConfidence":0.48,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:20.581Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.5,0.45,0.02],"clarity":[0.01,0.09,0.49,0.41]}},"durationMs":76,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":300,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €600; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €300.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0084","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"crew","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.99,"clarityScore":1.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.95,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:20.824Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.95,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.58,0.02,0.2,0.2]}},"durationMs":88,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"0% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.0/3, clarity 1.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0085","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.44,"clarityScore":2.33,"evidenceConfidence":0.5,"clarityConfidence":0.55,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:21.062Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.51,0.45,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.06,0.55,0.39]}},"durationMs":89,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.5,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6.9 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"50% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.4/3, clarity 2.3/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0086","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.8,"clarityScore":0.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.79,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:21.313Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.21,0.79,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":99,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"179 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 240 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 179 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0087","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.54,"clarityScore":2.4,"evidenceConfidence":0.51,"clarityConfidence":0.52,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:21.548Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.02,0.44,0.53,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.04,0.52,0.44]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0088","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"weather","evidence":"partial","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.45,"evidenceScore":2,"clarityScore":2.92,"evidenceConfidence":0.64,"clarityConfidence":0.92,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:21.781Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.18,0.64,0.18],"clarity":[0,0,0.08,0.92]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.55,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"180 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"45% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"55% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 2.0/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 90%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0089","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.41,"clarityScore":2.28,"evidenceConfidence":0.54,"clarityConfidence":0.48,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:22.015Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.55,0.41,0.01],"clarity":[0.01,0.1,0.49,0.4]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0090","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.37,"evidenceScore":1.1,"clarityScore":1.61,"evidenceConfidence":0.89,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:22.253Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.92,0.05,0.03],"clarity":[0.4,0.01,0.18,0.41]}},"durationMs":89,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"240 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"37% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"0% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.1/3, clarity 1.6/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0091","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.8,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.8,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:22.504Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.2,0.8,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":98,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.8,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"360 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"80% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0092","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.74,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.74,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:22.746Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.26,0.74,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":92,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0093","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.93,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.93,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:23.012Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.07,0.93,0,0],"clarity":[1,0,0,0]}},"durationMs":110,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":125,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €125.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0094","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"crew","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.98,"clarityScore":1.1,"evidenceConfidence":0.94,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:23.260Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.94,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.54,0.03,0.22,0.21]}},"durationMs":95,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0095","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.78,"clarityScore":0.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.78,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:23.529Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.22,0.78,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":118,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":200,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €200.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0096","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.74,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.72,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:23.767Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.05,0.15,0.79],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0097","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.72,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.72,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:24.021Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.28,0.72,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":100,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0098","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.43,"evidenceScore":1.12,"clarityScore":1.6,"evidenceConfidence":0.88,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:24.285Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.91,0.06,0.03],"clarity":[0.4,0.01,0.17,0.42]}},"durationMs":112,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"181 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"43% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"0% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.1/3, clarity 1.6/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0099","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.56,"clarityScore":2.99,"evidenceConfidence":0.25,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:24.515Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.13,0.34,0.38,0.15],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0100","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.68,"evidenceScore":2.52,"clarityScore":2.73,"evidenceConfidence":0.51,"clarityConfidence":0.72,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:24.748Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.14,0.18,0.67],"clarity":[0.08,0.01,0.02,0.89]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0101","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"weather","evidence":"partial","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.18,"evidenceScore":1.79,"clarityScore":2.53,"evidenceConfidence":0.54,"clarityConfidence":0.52,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:24.994Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.33,0.54,0.13],"clarity":[0.11,0.02,0.11,0.76]}},"durationMs":94,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0102","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.38,"clarityScore":0.14,"evidenceConfidence":0.63,"clarityConfidence":0.87,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:25.228Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.63,0.37,0,0],"clarity":[0.87,0.13,0,0]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0103","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.81,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.81,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:25.458Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.19,0.81,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":75,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.81,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"239 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"81% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0104","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.38,"clarityScore":0.12,"evidenceConfidence":0.62,"clarityConfidence":0.88,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:25.687Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.62,0.38,0,0],"clarity":[0.88,0.12,0,0]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0105","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.84,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.84,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:25.920Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.16,0.84,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0106","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.22,"clarityScore":0.09,"evidenceConfidence":0.79,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:26.152Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.79,0.21,0,0],"clarity":[0.91,0.09,0,0]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.79,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"241 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"79% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.2/3, clarity 0.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0107","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.73,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.29,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:26.399Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.29,0.39,0.22],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":92,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.29,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"29% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0108","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.03,"clarityScore":0.68,"evidenceConfidence":0.96,"clarityConfidence":0.31,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:26.631Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.96,0.03,0],"clarity":[0.67,0.08,0.14,0.11]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"179 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 179 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0109","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.92,"clarityScore":2.92,"evidenceConfidence":0.45,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:26.893Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.22,0.5,0.23],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.07,0.92]}},"durationMs":108,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"119 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 119 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0110","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.39,"clarityScore":2.19,"evidenceConfidence":0.53,"clarityConfidence":0.47,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:27.145Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.54,0.41,0.01],"clarity":[0.02,0.13,0.49,0.36]}},"durationMs":101,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0111","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.84,"clarityScore":2.86,"evidenceConfidence":0.41,"clarityConfidence":0.86,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:27.385Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.25,0.47,0.22],"clarity":[0,0.02,0.1,0.88]}},"durationMs":90,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0112","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.67,"clarityScore":2.99,"evidenceConfidence":0.31,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:27.695Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.31,0.41,0.18],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":154,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0113","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.26,"clarityScore":0.09,"evidenceConfidence":0.75,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:27.956Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.75,0.25,0,0],"clarity":[0.91,0.09,0,0]}},"durationMs":111,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":200,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €200.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0114","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.21,"clarityScore":0.09,"evidenceConfidence":0.8,"clarityConfidence":0.92,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:28.188Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.8,0.2,0,0],"clarity":[0.92,0.08,0,0]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":600,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €600; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €600.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0115","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.24,"evidenceScore":1.12,"clarityScore":1.38,"evidenceConfidence":0.87,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:28.419Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.91,0.05,0.04],"clarity":[0.5,0.01,0.12,0.37]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0116","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.72,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.28,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:28.657Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.11,0.28,0.39,0.22],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":84,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0117","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.79,"clarityScore":2.77,"evidenceConfidence":0.38,"clarityConfidence":0.76,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:28.902Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.29,0.44,0.21],"clarity":[0.03,0.02,0.11,0.84]}},"durationMs":94,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":600,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €600; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €600.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0118","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.37,"clarityScore":0.14,"evidenceConfidence":0.63,"clarityConfidence":0.86,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:29.142Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.63,0.37,0,0],"clarity":[0.86,0.14,0,0]}},"durationMs":86,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.63,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"63% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.4/3, clarity 0.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0119","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.9,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.9,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:29.372Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.9,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":74,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0.9,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"241 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"90% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.9/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0120","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"crew","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1,"clarityScore":0.97,"evidenceConfidence":0.96,"clarityConfidence":0.04,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:29.602Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.02,0.96,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.6,0.02,0.2,0.18]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0121","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.43,"clarityScore":2.34,"evidenceConfidence":0.51,"clarityConfidence":0.54,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:29.838Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.52,0.44,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.06,0.54,0.4]}},"durationMs":83,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.51,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"8 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"51% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.4/3, clarity 2.3/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0122","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.56,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.22,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:30.099Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.11,0.37,0.37,0.15],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":110,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":250,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €250.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0123","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.37,"clarityScore":0.17,"evidenceConfidence":0.63,"clarityConfidence":0.83,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:30.344Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.63,0.37,0,0],"clarity":[0.83,0.17,0,0]}},"durationMs":92,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"179 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 179 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0124","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.45,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.3,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:30.573Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.13,0.41,0.35,0.11],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":250,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €250.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0125","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.97,"evidenceScore":2.72,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.7,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:30.816Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.05,0.17,0.77],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":88,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.7,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"13 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"97% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"70% conservative judgment strength; 98% denial threshold. Evidence 2.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 98%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0126","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.82,"clarityScore":2.82,"evidenceConfidence":0.41,"clarityConfidence":0.83,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:31.092Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.28,0.46,0.21],"clarity":[0.02,0.02,0.07,0.89]}},"durationMs":125,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0127","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.66,"evidenceScore":2.47,"clarityScore":2.68,"evidenceConfidence":0.47,"clarityConfidence":0.68,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:31.335Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.17,0.16,0.66],"clarity":[0.09,0.01,0.03,0.87]}},"durationMs":84,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0128","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.91,"clarityScore":2.91,"evidenceConfidence":0.45,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:31.583Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.22,0.5,0.23],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.07,0.92]}},"durationMs":93,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.45,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"180 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"45% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.9/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0129","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.66,"evidenceScore":2.45,"clarityScore":2.75,"evidenceConfidence":0.47,"clarityConfidence":0.74,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:31.811Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.16,0.18,0.65],"clarity":[0.07,0.01,0.03,0.89]}},"durationMs":75,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0130","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.72,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.71,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:32.047Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.05,0.16,0.78],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":83,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.71,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"0 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"96% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"71% conservative judgment strength; 98% denial threshold. Evidence 2.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 98%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0131","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.83,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.82,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:32.373Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.18,0.82,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":172,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.82,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"180 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"82% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0132","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.39,"evidenceScore":1.09,"clarityScore":1.54,"evidenceConfidence":0.91,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:32.613Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.93,0.05,0.02],"clarity":[0.42,0.01,0.17,0.4]}},"durationMs":87,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"181 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"39% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"0% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.1/3, clarity 1.5/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0133","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.91,"clarityScore":2.87,"evidenceConfidence":0.39,"clarityConfidence":0.88,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:32.845Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.23,0.45,0.26],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.1,0.89]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.39,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"39% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.9/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0134","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.94,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.94,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:33.080Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.94,0,0],"clarity":[1,0,0,0]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"119 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 119 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0135","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.19,"clarityScore":0.1,"evidenceConfidence":0.82,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:33.315Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.82,0.18,0,0],"clarity":[0.9,0.1,0,0]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.82,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"241 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"82% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.2/3, clarity 0.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0136","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.22,"clarityScore":0.1,"evidenceConfidence":0.79,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:33.547Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.79,0.21,0,0],"clarity":[0.9,0.1,0,0]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"179 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 179 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0137","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.65,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.65,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:33.792Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.35,0.65,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":93,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0138","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.89,"clarityScore":2.92,"evidenceConfidence":0.45,"clarityConfidence":0.92,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:34.028Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.21,0.51,0.22],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.06,0.93]}},"durationMs":84,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0139","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"crew","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.36,"clarityScore":2.68,"evidenceConfidence":0.52,"clarityConfidence":0.69,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:34.268Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.53,0.4,0.01],"clarity":[0,0,0.31,0.6900000000000001]}},"durationMs":86,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0140","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.67,"evidenceScore":2.49,"clarityScore":2.78,"evidenceConfidence":0.49,"clarityConfidence":0.78,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:34.527Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.15,0.18,0.66],"clarity":[0.06,0.01,0.02,0.91]}},"durationMs":206,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":200,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €200.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0141","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.75,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.29,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:34.862Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.28,0.39,0.23],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.29,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"29% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.8/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0142","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.72,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.3,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:35.097Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.29,0.4,0.21],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0143","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.91,"clarityScore":0.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.9,"clarityConfidence":0.98,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:35.326Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.9,0,0],"clarity":[0.98,0.02,0,0]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0144","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.25,"clarityScore":0.09,"evidenceConfidence":0.76,"clarityConfidence":0.92,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:35.561Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.76,0.24,0,0],"clarity":[0.92,0.08,0,0]}},"durationMs":83,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0145","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.78,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.78,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:35.799Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.22,0.78,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":85,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0146","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.75,"clarityScore":2.99,"evidenceConfidence":0.32,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:36.064Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.09,0.28,0.41000000000000003,0.22],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":113,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0147","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.19,"clarityScore":0.09,"evidenceConfidence":0.81,"clarityConfidence":0.92,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:36.307Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.81,0.19,0,0],"clarity":[0.92,0.08,0,0]}},"durationMs":91,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":250,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €250.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0148","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.25,"clarityScore":0.1,"evidenceConfidence":0.76,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:36.537Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.76,0.24,0,0],"clarity":[0.9,0.1,0,0]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0149","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.67,"evidenceScore":2.42,"clarityScore":2.72,"evidenceConfidence":0.41,"clarityConfidence":0.72,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:36.786Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.02,0.16,0.21,0.61],"clarity":[0.08,0.01,0.02,0.89]}},"durationMs":93,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":300,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €600; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €300.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0150","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.87,"clarityScore":2.89,"evidenceConfidence":0.41,"clarityConfidence":0.89,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:37.074Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.26,0.46,0.23],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.09,0.9]}},"durationMs":136,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.41,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6.9 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"41% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.9/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0151","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.2,"clarityScore":0.1,"evidenceConfidence":0.8,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:37.308Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.8,0.2,0,0],"clarity":[0.91,0.09,0,0]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0152","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.35,"clarityScore":0.18,"evidenceConfidence":0.65,"clarityConfidence":0.83,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:37.553Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.65,0.35,0,0],"clarity":[0.83,0.17,0,0]}},"durationMs":93,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.65,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"13.9 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"65% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.3/3, clarity 0.2/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0153","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.69,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.69,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:37.801Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.31,0.69,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":98,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0154","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.37,"clarityScore":2.18,"evidenceConfidence":0.55,"clarityConfidence":0.47,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:38.079Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.56,0.39,0.01],"clarity":[0.02,0.13,0.49,0.36]}},"durationMs":123,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0155","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"crew","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.99,"clarityScore":0.96,"evidenceConfidence":0.95,"clarityConfidence":0.04,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:38.308Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.95,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.59,0.03,0.21,0.17]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0.04,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"13 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"4% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.0/3, clarity 1.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0156","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.82,"clarityScore":0.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.82,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:38.546Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.18,0.8200000000000001,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0157","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.67,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.67,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:38.780Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.33,0.67,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.67,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6.9 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"67% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.7/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0158","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.81,"clarityScore":2.78,"evidenceConfidence":0.42,"clarityConfidence":0.77,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:39.014Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.28,0.47,0.2],"clarity":[0.03,0.03,0.08,0.86]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":600,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €600; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €600.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0159","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.19,"clarityScore":0.12,"evidenceConfidence":0.82,"clarityConfidence":0.88,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:39.275Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.82,0.18,0,0],"clarity":[0.88,0.12,0,0]}},"durationMs":107,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0160","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.03,"clarityScore":0.7,"evidenceConfidence":0.96,"clarityConfidence":0.3,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:39.510Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.96,0.03,0],"clarity":[0.66,0.09,0.14,0.11]}},"durationMs":83,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.3,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"240 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"30% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.0/3, clarity 0.7/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0161","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.44,"clarityScore":2.37,"evidenceConfidence":0.5,"clarityConfidence":0.52,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:39.748Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.51,0.45,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.05,0.52,0.43]}},"durationMs":85,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.5,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"13.9 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"50% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.4/3, clarity 2.4/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0162","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.78,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.77,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:39.992Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.23,0.77,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":90,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":250,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €250.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0163","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.78,"clarityScore":2.78,"evidenceConfidence":0.41,"clarityConfidence":0.77,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:40.230Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.29,0.47,0.18],"clarity":[0.03,0.03,0.08,0.86]}},"durationMs":87,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":250,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €250.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0164","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.82,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.81,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:40.457Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.19,0.81,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":74,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0.81,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"360 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"81% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 240 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0165","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.72,"clarityScore":2.99,"evidenceConfidence":0.71,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:40.716Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.05,0.16,0.78],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":107,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.71,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"241 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"96% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"71% conservative judgment strength; 98% denial threshold. Evidence 2.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 98%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0166","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"weather","evidence":"partial","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.37,"evidenceScore":2.01,"clarityScore":2.92,"evidenceConfidence":0.69,"clarityConfidence":0.92,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:40.949Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.15,0.69,0.16],"clarity":[0,0,0.08,0.92]}},"durationMs":195,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.63,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"240 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"37% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"63% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 2.0/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 90%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0167","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"crew","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.29,"clarityScore":2.68,"evidenceConfidence":0.56,"clarityConfidence":0.69,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:41.291Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.08,0.57,0.34,0.01],"clarity":[0,0,0.31,0.69]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0168","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.89,"clarityScore":0.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.89,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:41.522Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.11,0.89,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0169","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.75,"clarityScore":2.71,"evidenceConfidence":0.39,"clarityConfidence":0.7,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:41.772Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.33,0.44,0.18],"clarity":[0.05,0.03,0.09,0.83]}},"durationMs":99,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0170","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.91,"clarityScore":0.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.91,"clarityConfidence":0.98,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:42.001Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.09,0.91,0,0],"clarity":[0.98,0.02,0,0]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.91,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6.9 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"91% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.9/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0171","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.19,"clarityScore":0.11,"evidenceConfidence":0.81,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:42.227Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.81,0.19,0,0],"clarity":[0.9,0.1,0,0]}},"durationMs":74,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.81,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"13 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"81% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.2/3, clarity 0.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0172","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"crew","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.26,"clarityScore":2.69,"evidenceConfidence":0.54,"clarityConfidence":0.7,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:42.465Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.55,0.34,0.01],"clarity":[0,0,0.3,0.7]}},"durationMs":86,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.54,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"241 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"54% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.3/3, clarity 2.7/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0173","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"weather","evidence":"partial","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.43,"evidenceScore":1.98,"clarityScore":2.92,"evidenceConfidence":0.7,"clarityConfidence":0.92,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:42.698Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.16,0.7,0.14],"clarity":[0,0,0.08,0.92]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"179 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 120 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 179 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0174","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.59,"clarityScore":2.38,"evidenceConfidence":0.58,"clarityConfidence":0.55,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:42.927Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.39,0.59,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.03,0.55,0.42]}},"durationMs":76,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.55,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"239 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"55% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.6/3, clarity 2.4/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0175","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.25,"clarityScore":0.1,"evidenceConfidence":0.75,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:43.162Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.75,0.25,0,0],"clarity":[0.91,0.09,0,0]}},"durationMs":85,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0176","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.87,"clarityScore":0.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.87,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:43.408Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.13,0.87,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":92,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":250,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €250.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0177","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"crew","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.99,"clarityScore":1.04,"evidenceConfidence":0.95,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:43.635Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.95,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.57,0.02,0.21,0.2]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0178","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.96,"clarityScore":2.93,"evidenceConfidence":0.46,"clarityConfidence":0.93,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:43.873Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.21,0.5,0.25],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.05,0.94]}},"durationMs":88,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.46,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"180 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"46% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 2.0/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0179","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.43,"evidenceScore":1.1,"clarityScore":1.57,"evidenceConfidence":0.89,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:44.107Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.92,0.05,0.03],"clarity":[0.41,0.01,0.17,0.41]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0180","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.74,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.73,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:44.343Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.05,0.14,0.8],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"119 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 119 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0181","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.88,"clarityScore":2.87,"evidenceConfidence":0.45,"clarityConfidence":0.87,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:44.575Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.25,0.49,0.22],"clarity":[0,0.02,0.09,0.89]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0182","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.2,"clarityScore":0.11,"evidenceConfidence":0.8,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:44.819Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.8,0.2,0,0],"clarity":[0.9,0.1,0,0]}},"durationMs":96,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.8,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"13 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"80% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.2/3, clarity 0.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0183","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.66,"evidenceScore":2.45,"clarityScore":2.75,"evidenceConfidence":0.46,"clarityConfidence":0.75,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:45.066Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.16,0.19,0.64],"clarity":[0.07,0.01,0.02,0.9]}},"durationMs":87,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0184","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.71,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.71,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:45.301Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.05,0.16,0.78],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0185","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.81,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.8,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:45.549Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.2,0.8,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":98,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0.8,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6.9 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"80% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0186","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.42,"clarityScore":2.35,"evidenceConfidence":0.52,"clarityConfidence":0.55,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:45.806Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.53,0.43,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.05,0.55,0.4]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.52,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6.9 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"52% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.4/3, clarity 2.4/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0187","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.71,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.71,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:46.041Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.29,0.71,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":85,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"179 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 179 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0188","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"crew","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.01,"clarityScore":1.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.96,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:46.290Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.02,0.96,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.57,0.03,0.21,0.19]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"239 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"0% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.0/3, clarity 1.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0189","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.85,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.84,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:46.523Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.16,0.84,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.84,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"13.9 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"84% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0190","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.65,"evidenceScore":2.51,"clarityScore":2.79,"evidenceConfidence":0.51,"clarityConfidence":0.78,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:46.763Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.14,0.18,0.67],"clarity":[0.06,0.01,0.02,0.91]}},"durationMs":88,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0191","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.71,"evidenceScore":2.47,"clarityScore":2.77,"evidenceConfidence":0.48,"clarityConfidence":0.77,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:47.000Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.15,0.19,0.65],"clarity":[0.06,0.01,0.03,0.9]}},"durationMs":84,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0192","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.5,"clarityScore":2.37,"evidenceConfidence":0.47,"clarityConfidence":0.53,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:47.244Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.46,0.5,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.05,0.53,0.42]}},"durationMs":92,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0.47,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"47% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.5/3, clarity 2.4/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0193","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.79,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.79,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:47.482Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.21,0.79,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0194","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":2,"clarityScore":2.93,"evidenceConfidence":0.47,"clarityConfidence":0.92,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:47.736Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.19,0.51,0.26],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.06,0.9299999999999999]}},"durationMs":105,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0195","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"weather","evidence":"partial","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.45,"evidenceScore":1.97,"clarityScore":2.92,"evidenceConfidence":0.7,"clarityConfidence":0.92,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:48.013Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.16,0.7,0.14],"clarity":[0,0,0.08,0.92]}},"durationMs":125,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"119 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 119 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0196","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.81,"clarityScore":0.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.81,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:48.253Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.19,0.81,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":87,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":600,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €600; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €600.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0197","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.72,"evidenceScore":2.54,"clarityScore":2.84,"evidenceConfidence":0.53,"clarityConfidence":0.84,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:48.487Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.13,0.18,0.68],"clarity":[0.04,0.01,0.02,0.93]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0198","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.73,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.29,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:48.722Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.29,0.39,0.22],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.29,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"29% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0199","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.76,"clarityScore":2.8,"evidenceConfidence":0.4,"clarityConfidence":0.81,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:48.949Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.3,0.46,0.18],"clarity":[0.02,0.02,0.09,0.87]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0200","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.86,"clarityScore":2.87,"evidenceConfidence":0.4,"clarityConfidence":0.88,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:49.196Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.27,0.45,0.23],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.1,0.89]}},"durationMs":89,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0201","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.79,"clarityScore":2.81,"evidenceConfidence":0.41,"clarityConfidence":0.82,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:49.473Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.3,0.46,0.19],"clarity":[0.02,0.02,0.08,0.88]}},"durationMs":125,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0202","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.66,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.66,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:49.705Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.34,0.66,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":250,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €250.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0203","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.34,"clarityScore":0.13,"evidenceConfidence":0.66,"clarityConfidence":0.87,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:49.955Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.66,0.34,0,0],"clarity":[0.87,0.13,0,0]}},"durationMs":153,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0204","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.01,"clarityScore":0.44,"evidenceConfidence":0.96,"clarityConfidence":0.56,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:50.244Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.02,0.96,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.78,0.07,0.08,0.07]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0205","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.41,"clarityScore":2.27,"evidenceConfidence":0.53,"clarityConfidence":0.49,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:50.519Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.54,0.42,0.01],"clarity":[0.01,0.1,0.5,0.39]}},"durationMs":119,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0206","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.83,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.83,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:50.751Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.17,0.83,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.83,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"0 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"83% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0207","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.81,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.8,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:50.985Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.2,0.8,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0208","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.98,"clarityScore":2.92,"evidenceConfidence":0.48,"clarityConfidence":0.92,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:51.232Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.2,0.52,0.24],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.06,0.93]}},"durationMs":93,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0209","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.67,"evidenceScore":2.44,"clarityScore":2.78,"evidenceConfidence":0.44,"clarityConfidence":0.78,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:51.465Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.16,0.21,0.62],"clarity":[0.06,0.01,0.02,0.91]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":250,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €250.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0210","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.79,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.78,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:51.695Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.22,0.78,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0211","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.72,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.72,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:51.931Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.28,0.72,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"179 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 179 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0212","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.75,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.31,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:52.160Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.27,0.41,0.22],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0213","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.53,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.26,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:52.399Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.12,0.36,0.38,0.14],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":89,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0214","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.77,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.77,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:52.663Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.23,0.77,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":107,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.77,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"8 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"77% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0215","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.71,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.71,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:52.901Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.29,0.71,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":85,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0.71,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"240 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"71% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.7/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0216","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.2,"clarityScore":0.11,"evidenceConfidence":0.81,"clarityConfidence":0.89,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:53.133Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.81,0.19,0,0],"clarity":[0.89,0.11,0,0]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.81,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"81% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.2/3, clarity 0.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0217","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":2,"clarityScore":2.9,"evidenceConfidence":0.47,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:53.367Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.21,0.5,0.26],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.08,0.91]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"119 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 240 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 119 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0218","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.83,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.83,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:53.592Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.17,0.83,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":75,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.83,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"180 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"83% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0219","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.24,"clarityScore":0.09,"evidenceConfidence":0.77,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:53.826Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.77,0.23,0,0],"clarity":[0.91,0.09,0,0]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"179 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 179 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0220","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.58,"clarityScore":2.42,"evidenceConfidence":0.57,"clarityConfidence":0.52,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:54.060Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.4,0.58,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.03,0.52,0.45]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.52,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"180 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"52% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.6/3, clarity 2.4/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0221","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.36,"clarityScore":0.12,"evidenceConfidence":0.64,"clarityConfidence":0.88,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:54.304Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.64,0.36,0,0],"clarity":[0.88,0.12,0,0]}},"durationMs":90,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0222","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.25,"clarityScore":0.1,"evidenceConfidence":0.76,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:54.576Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.76,0.24,0,0],"clarity":[0.9,0.1,0,0]}},"durationMs":119,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":200,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €200.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0223","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.97,"evidenceScore":2.73,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.72,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:54.806Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.04,0.17,0.78],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":75,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0224","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.27,"clarityScore":0.1,"evidenceConfidence":0.74,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:55.046Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.74,0.26,0,0],"clarity":[0.91,0.09,0,0]}},"durationMs":84,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0225","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"crew","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.28,"clarityScore":2.66,"evidenceConfidence":0.55,"clarityConfidence":0.67,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:55.292Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.08,0.5599999999999999,0.35,0.01],"clarity":[0,0,0.33,0.67]}},"durationMs":92,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.55,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"239 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"55% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.3/3, clarity 2.7/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0226","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.92,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.92,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:55.546Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.08,0.92,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":100,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.92,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"0 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"92% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.9/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0227","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.8,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.8,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:55.780Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.2,0.8,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0228","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.97,"evidenceScore":2.72,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.71,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:56.017Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.05,0.16,0.78],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":141,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0229","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.93,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.93,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:56.314Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.07,0.93,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":86,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.93,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"13.9 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"93% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.9/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0230","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.67,"evidenceScore":2.51,"clarityScore":2.79,"evidenceConfidence":0.51,"clarityConfidence":0.77,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:56.567Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.13,0.2,0.66],"clarity":[0.06,0.01,0.03,0.9]}},"durationMs":101,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0231","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.21,"clarityScore":0.1,"evidenceConfidence":0.79,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:56.812Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.79,0.21,0,0],"clarity":[0.9,0.1,0,0]}},"durationMs":93,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0232","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.02,"clarityScore":0.64,"evidenceConfidence":0.96,"clarityConfidence":0.34,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:57.063Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.96,0.03,0],"clarity":[0.67,0.1,0.13,0.1]}},"durationMs":98,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0233","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.91,"clarityScore":2.86,"evidenceConfidence":0.46,"clarityConfidence":0.88,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:57.294Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.23,0.5,0.23],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.1,0.89]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0234","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.04,"clarityScore":0.71,"evidenceConfidence":0.95,"clarityConfidence":0.29,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:57.531Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.95,0.04,0],"clarity":[0.66,0.08,0.15,0.11]}},"durationMs":90,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.29,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"180 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"29% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.0/3, clarity 0.7/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0235","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.01,"clarityScore":0.51,"evidenceConfidence":0.97,"clarityConfidence":0.48,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:57.777Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.97,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.74,0.09,0.08,0.09]}},"durationMs":88,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0236","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.71,"clarityScore":2.99,"evidenceConfidence":0.3,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:58.011Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.09,0.32,0.39,0.2],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0237","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.42,"evidenceScore":1.1,"clarityScore":1.64,"evidenceConfidence":0.91,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:58.243Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.93,0.05,0.02],"clarity":[0.39,0.01,0.18,0.42]}},"durationMs":86,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0238","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"crew","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.26,"clarityScore":2.7,"evidenceConfidence":0.56,"clarityConfidence":0.69,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:58.484Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.09,0.57,0.33,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.29,0.7]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":125,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €125.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0239","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.23,"clarityScore":0.09,"evidenceConfidence":0.78,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:58.730Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.78,0.22,0,0],"clarity":[0.91,0.09,0,0]}},"durationMs":91,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":600,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €600; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €600.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0240","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.26,"clarityScore":0.09,"evidenceConfidence":0.75,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:58.993Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.75,0.25,0,0],"clarity":[0.91,0.09,0,0]}},"durationMs":94,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0241","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.23,"clarityScore":0.1,"evidenceConfidence":0.77,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:59.232Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.77,0.23,0,0],"clarity":[0.9,0.1,0,0]}},"durationMs":87,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.77,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"77% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.2/3, clarity 0.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0242","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"weather","evidence":"partial","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.41,"evidenceScore":1.98,"clarityScore":2.91,"evidenceConfidence":0.69,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:59.476Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.16,0.6900000000000001,0.15],"clarity":[0,0,0.09,0.91]}},"durationMs":92,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"119 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 119 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0243","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.74,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.73,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:59.711Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.04,0.16,0.79],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":84,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0244","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.25,"clarityScore":0.1,"evidenceConfidence":0.76,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:32:59.948Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.76,0.24,0,0],"clarity":[0.91,0.09,0,0]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.76,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"360 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"76% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.3/3, clarity 0.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0245","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.94,"clarityScore":0,"evidenceConfidence":0.94,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:00.179Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.94,0,0],"clarity":[1,0,0,0]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.94,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"8 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"94% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.9/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0246","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.98,"clarityScore":2.89,"evidenceConfidence":0.45,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:00.411Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.21,0.49,0.26],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.08,0.91]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0247","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.92,"clarityScore":2.91,"evidenceConfidence":0.44,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:00.681Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.2,0.5,0.24],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.07,0.92]}},"durationMs":112,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.44,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"240 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"44% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.9/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0248","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"crew","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.36,"clarityScore":2.66,"evidenceConfidence":0.51,"clarityConfidence":0.67,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:00.910Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.07,0.52,0.4,0.01],"clarity":[0,0,0.33,0.67]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0249","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.63,"clarityScore":2.99,"evidenceConfidence":0.31,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:01.143Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.11,0.31,0.42,0.16],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0.31,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"181 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"31% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.6/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0250","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.91,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.91,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:01.380Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.09,0.91,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":84,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0251","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.77,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.3,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:01.618Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.26,0.4,0.24],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":83,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.3,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"0 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"30% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.8/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0252","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.94,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.94,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:01.878Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.9400000000000001,0,0],"clarity":[1,0,0,0]}},"durationMs":110,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.94,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"94% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.9/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0253","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.35,"clarityScore":0.14,"evidenceConfidence":0.65,"clarityConfidence":0.86,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:02.133Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.65,0.35,0,0],"clarity":[0.86,0.14,0,0]}},"durationMs":103,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.65,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"0 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"65% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.3/3, clarity 0.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0254","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.75,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.77,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:02.369Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.04,0.15,0.81],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.77,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"239 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"96% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"77% conservative judgment strength; 98% denial threshold. Evidence 2.8/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 98%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0255","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.64,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.3,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:02.599Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.34,0.39999999999999997,0.16],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.3,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"360 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"30% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.6/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0256","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.23,"clarityScore":0.12,"evidenceConfidence":0.77,"clarityConfidence":0.89,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:02.838Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.77,0.23,0,0],"clarity":[0.89,0.11,0,0]}},"durationMs":89,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0257","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.71,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.71,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:03.080Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.29,0.71,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":87,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"179 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 179 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0258","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.94,"clarityScore":2.91,"evidenceConfidence":0.52,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:03.313Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.21,0.55,0.21],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.07,0.92]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0.52,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"360 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"52% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.9/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 240 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0259","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.85,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.84,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:03.544Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.16,0.84,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":92,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.84,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"180 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"84% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0260","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"weather","evidence":"partial","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.19,"evidenceScore":1.78,"clarityScore":2.55,"evidenceConfidence":0.53,"clarityConfidence":0.55,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:03.815Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.33,0.54,0.12],"clarity":[0.1,0.02,0.11,0.77]}},"durationMs":83,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0261","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.81,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.81,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:04.067Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.19,0.81,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":100,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.81,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"360 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"81% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0262","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.77,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.77,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:04.300Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.23,0.77,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.77,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"8 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"77% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0263","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.17,"clarityScore":0.12,"evidenceConfidence":0.83,"clarityConfidence":0.88,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:04.597Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.83,0.17,0,0],"clarity":[0.88,0.12,0,0]}},"durationMs":144,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.83,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"83% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.2/3, clarity 0.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0264","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.69,"evidenceScore":2.44,"clarityScore":2.79,"evidenceConfidence":0.44,"clarityConfidence":0.78,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:04.841Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.16,0.21,0.62],"clarity":[0.06,0.01,0.02,0.91]}},"durationMs":95,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":250,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €250.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0265","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"crew","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.99,"clarityScore":1.19,"evidenceConfidence":0.95,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:05.095Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.95,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.52,0.02,0.22,0.24]}},"durationMs":99,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":200,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €200.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0266","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.39,"clarityScore":0.13,"evidenceConfidence":0.61,"clarityConfidence":0.87,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:05.329Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.61,0.39,0,0],"clarity":[0.87,0.13,0,0]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.61,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"360 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"61% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.4/3, clarity 0.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0267","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.82,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.81,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:05.559Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.19,0.81,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":131,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":600,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €600; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €600.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0268","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"weather","evidence":"partial","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.49,"evidenceScore":2,"clarityScore":2.93,"evidenceConfidence":0.67,"clarityConfidence":0.93,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:05.845Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.16,0.67,0.17],"clarity":[0,0,0.07,0.93]}},"durationMs":84,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.51,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"180 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"49% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"51% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 2.0/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 90%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0269","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.94,"clarityScore":0,"evidenceConfidence":0.94,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:06.106Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.9400000000000001,0,0],"clarity":[1,0,0,0]}},"durationMs":109,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"119 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 119 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0270","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.75,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.28,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:06.349Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.11,0.27,0.39,0.23],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":89,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.28,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"8 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"28% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.8/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0271","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.89,"clarityScore":2.87,"evidenceConfidence":0.42,"clarityConfidence":0.89,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:06.582Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.25,0.47,0.23],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.09,0.9]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.42,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"8 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"42% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.9/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0272","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.23,"evidenceScore":1.1,"clarityScore":1.29,"evidenceConfidence":0.89,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:06.813Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.92,0.05,0.03],"clarity":[0.51,0.02,0.12,0.35]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0273","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.19,"clarityScore":0.1,"evidenceConfidence":0.82,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:07.070Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.82,0.18,0,0],"clarity":[0.9,0.1,0,0]}},"durationMs":105,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.82,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"360 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"82% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.2/3, clarity 0.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0274","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.23,"clarityScore":0.12,"evidenceConfidence":0.78,"clarityConfidence":0.88,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:07.316Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.78,0.22,0,0],"clarity":[0.88,0.12,0,0]}},"durationMs":91,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0275","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"crew","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.21,"clarityScore":2.66,"evidenceConfidence":0.57,"clarityConfidence":0.66,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:07.549Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.11,0.58,0.3,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.32,0.67]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0276","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.68,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.68,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:07.774Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.32,0.68,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":75,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0277","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.74,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.77,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:08.074Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.04,0.15,0.81],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":147,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.77,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"96% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"77% conservative judgment strength; 98% denial threshold. Evidence 2.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 98%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0278","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.57,"clarityScore":2.41,"evidenceConfidence":0.54,"clarityConfidence":0.51,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:08.311Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.02,0.41,0.56,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.04,0.51,0.45]}},"durationMs":84,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"179 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 179 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0279","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"weather","evidence":"partial","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.44,"evidenceScore":1.93,"clarityScore":2.89,"evidenceConfidence":0.66,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:08.552Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.2,0.66,0.14],"clarity":[0,0,0.1,0.9]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"179 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 179 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0280","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.77,"clarityScore":2.99,"evidenceConfidence":0.78,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:08.800Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.04,0.14,0.82],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":96,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.78,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"239 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"96% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"78% conservative judgment strength; 98% denial threshold. Evidence 2.8/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 98%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0281","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.76,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.75,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:09.055Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.04,0.14,0.8099999999999999],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":105,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.75,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"181 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"96% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"75% conservative judgment strength; 98% denial threshold. Evidence 2.8/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 98%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0282","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.22,"evidenceScore":1.12,"clarityScore":1.39,"evidenceConfidence":0.88,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:09.293Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.91,0.06,0.03],"clarity":[0.48,0.02,0.12,0.38]}},"durationMs":85,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0283","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.73,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.72,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:09.587Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.05,0.15,0.79],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":140,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0284","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.56,"clarityScore":2.41,"evidenceConfidence":0.52,"clarityConfidence":0.51,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:09.830Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.02,0.42,0.54,0.02],"clarity":[0,0.04,0.51,0.45]}},"durationMs":89,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.51,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"241 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"51% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.6/3, clarity 2.4/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0285","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.19,"clarityScore":0.1,"evidenceConfidence":0.81,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:10.071Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.81,0.19,0,0],"clarity":[0.91,0.09,0,0]}},"durationMs":125,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0286","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.95,"evidenceScore":2.72,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.72,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:10.340Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.05,0.15,0.79],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.72,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"360 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"95% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"72% conservative judgment strength; 98% denial threshold. Evidence 2.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 98%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0287","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.97,"evidenceScore":2.67,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.66,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:10.571Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.06,0.19,0.74],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.66,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"97% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"66% conservative judgment strength; 98% denial threshold. Evidence 2.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 98%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0288","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.78,"clarityScore":2.81,"evidenceConfidence":0.4,"clarityConfidence":0.8,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:10.820Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.31,0.45,0.19],"clarity":[0.03,0.02,0.07,0.88]}},"durationMs":104,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0289","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.35,"clarityScore":0.15,"evidenceConfidence":0.65,"clarityConfidence":0.85,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:11.062Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.65,0.35,0,0],"clarity":[0.85,0.15,0,0]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.65,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6.9 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"65% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.3/3, clarity 0.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0290","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.02,"clarityScore":0.69,"evidenceConfidence":0.97,"clarityConfidence":0.33,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:11.302Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.97,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.67,0.09,0.14,0.1]}},"durationMs":89,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0291","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.79,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.79,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:11.553Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.21,0.79,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":100,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.79,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"239 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"79% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0292","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.24,"evidenceScore":1.08,"clarityScore":1.65,"evidenceConfidence":0.92,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:11.804Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.93,0.04,0.02],"clarity":[0.4,0.01,0.13,0.46]}},"durationMs":96,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":200,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €200.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0293","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.7,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.7,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:12.035Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.3,0.7,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.7,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"70% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.7/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0294","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.25,"clarityScore":0.09,"evidenceConfidence":0.76,"clarityConfidence":0.92,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:12.287Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.76,0.24,0,0],"clarity":[0.92,0.08,0,0]}},"durationMs":98,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0295","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.83,"clarityScore":2.75,"evidenceConfidence":0.38,"clarityConfidence":0.74,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:12.523Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.3,0.43,0.22],"clarity":[0.04,0.03,0.08,0.85]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0296","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.9,"clarityScore":0.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.9,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:12.758Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.9,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":85,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0297","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.82,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.81,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:13.026Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.19,0.81,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":115,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0.81,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"180 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"81% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 240 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0298","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.37,"clarityScore":0.14,"evidenceConfidence":0.63,"clarityConfidence":0.86,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:13.255Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.63,0.37,0,0],"clarity":[0.86,0.14,0,0]}},"durationMs":74,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.63,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"63% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.4/3, clarity 0.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0299","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.71,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.69,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:13.518Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.05,0.18,0.76],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":85,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0300","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.39,"evidenceScore":1.1,"clarityScore":1.38,"evidenceConfidence":0.89,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:13.752Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.92,0.05,0.03],"clarity":[0.47,0.01,0.17,0.35]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"0 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"39% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"0% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.1/3, clarity 1.4/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0301","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.79,"clarityScore":0.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.79,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:13.982Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.21,0.79,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0302","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.64,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.26,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:14.213Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.12,0.31,0.38,0.19],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0.26,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"241 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"26% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.6/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 240 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0303","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.69,"evidenceScore":2.54,"clarityScore":2.81,"evidenceConfidence":0.54,"clarityConfidence":0.81,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:14.447Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.13,0.17,0.69],"clarity":[0.05,0.01,0.02,0.92]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0304","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.44,"evidenceScore":1.12,"clarityScore":1.52,"evidenceConfidence":0.88,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:14.678Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.91,0.06,0.03],"clarity":[0.43,0.01,0.17,0.39]}},"durationMs":76,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"181 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"44% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"0% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.1/3, clarity 1.5/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0305","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.79,"clarityScore":2.81,"evidenceConfidence":0.39,"clarityConfidence":0.82,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:14.925Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.29,0.45,0.2],"clarity":[0.02,0.02,0.08,0.88]}},"durationMs":93,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0306","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.8,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.8,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:15.163Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.2,0.8,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":86,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.8,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"180 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"80% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0307","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.88,"clarityScore":2.9,"evidenceConfidence":0.41,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:15.394Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.25,0.46,0.24],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.07,0.92]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0308","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.25,"clarityScore":0.09,"evidenceConfidence":0.76,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:15.628Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.76,0.24,0,0],"clarity":[0.91,0.09,0,0]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"119 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 119 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0309","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"weather","evidence":"partial","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.2,"evidenceScore":1.72,"clarityScore":2.6,"evidenceConfidence":0.52,"clarityConfidence":0.61,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:15.863Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.36,0.53,0.1],"clarity":[0.08,0.02,0.11,0.79]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0310","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.66,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.33,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:16.097Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.31,0.43,0.16],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.33,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"8 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"33% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0311","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.22,"clarityScore":0.1,"evidenceConfidence":0.79,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:16.366Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.79,0.21,0,0],"clarity":[0.9,0.1,0,0]}},"durationMs":116,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.79,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"240 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"79% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.2/3, clarity 0.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0312","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"crew","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.32,"clarityScore":2.67,"evidenceConfidence":0.54,"clarityConfidence":0.69,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:16.632Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.07,0.55,0.37,0.01],"clarity":[0,0,0.31,0.6900000000000001]}},"durationMs":111,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.54,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"54% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.3/3, clarity 2.7/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0313","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.66,"clarityScore":2.99,"evidenceConfidence":0.3,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:16.864Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.32,0.4,0.18],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0314","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.53,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.23,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:17.105Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.12,0.37,0.37,0.14],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":88,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0315","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.24,"clarityScore":0.16,"evidenceConfidence":0.77,"clarityConfidence":0.84,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:17.364Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.77,0.23,0,0],"clarity":[0.84,0.16,0,0]}},"durationMs":107,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.77,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"180 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"77% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.2/3, clarity 0.2/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0316","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.94,"clarityScore":2.89,"evidenceConfidence":0.41,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:17.621Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.23,0.45999999999999996,0.26],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.08,0.91]}},"durationMs":105,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.41,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"41% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.9/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0317","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.81,"clarityScore":2.81,"evidenceConfidence":0.42,"clarityConfidence":0.83,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:17.905Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.29,0.47,0.19],"clarity":[0.02,0.02,0.07,0.89]}},"durationMs":127,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0318","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.8,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.79,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:18.155Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.21,0.79,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":100,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"<7 days notice; replacement departs ≤1 hour early and arrives <2 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"<7 days notice; replacement departs ≤1 hour early and arrives <2 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0319","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.62,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.28,"clarityConfidence":0.98,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:18.387Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.11,0.33,0.39,0.17],"clarity":[0,0,0.02,0.98]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.28,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"0 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"28% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.6/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0320","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.97,"evidenceScore":2.74,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.75,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:18.717Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.04,0.17,0.79],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":179,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0321","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.75,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.33,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:18.952Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.09,0.28,0.42,0.21],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0322","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.75,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.31,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:19.208Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.27,0.41,0.22],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":86,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.31,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"13 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"31% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.8/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0323","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"crew","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.99,"clarityScore":1.04,"evidenceConfidence":0.95,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:19.475Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.95,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.5599999999999999,0.03,0.21,0.2]}},"durationMs":115,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0324","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":2.01,"clarityScore":2.93,"evidenceConfidence":0.46,"clarityConfidence":0.95,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:19.711Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.18,0.5,0.28],"clarity":[0,0,0.05,0.95]}},"durationMs":83,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0325","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.81,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.81,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:19.941Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.19,0.81,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0326","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.76,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.75,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:20.174Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.04,0.14,0.81],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0327","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.94,"clarityScore":2.9,"evidenceConfidence":0.48,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:20.401Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.21,0.52,0.23],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.08,0.91]}},"durationMs":73,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.48,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"181 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"48% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.9/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0328","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.8,"clarityScore":2.81,"evidenceConfidence":0.43,"clarityConfidence":0.82,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:20.638Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.28,0.48,0.19],"clarity":[0.02,0.02,0.08,0.88]}},"durationMs":87,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0329","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"crew","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1,"clarityScore":1.08,"evidenceConfidence":0.95,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:20.881Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.95,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.56,0.02,0.21,0.21]}},"durationMs":87,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"0 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"0% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.0/3, clarity 1.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0330","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.75,"clarityScore":2.99,"evidenceConfidence":0.29,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:21.117Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.11,0.26,0.4,0.23],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":85,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0.29,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"29% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.8/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0331","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.38,"clarityScore":0.12,"evidenceConfidence":0.63,"clarityConfidence":0.88,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:21.351Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.63,0.37,0,0],"clarity":[0.88,0.12,0,0]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0332","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.85,"clarityScore":2.75,"evidenceConfidence":0.44,"clarityConfidence":0.76,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:21.582Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.25,0.49,0.21],"clarity":[0.03,0.03,0.09,0.85]}},"durationMs":76,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0333","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.41,"evidenceScore":1.09,"clarityScore":1.51,"evidenceConfidence":0.91,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:21.836Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.93,0.05,0.02],"clarity":[0.43,0.01,0.18,0.38]}},"durationMs":100,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0334","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.79,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.79,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:22.070Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.21,0.79,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0335","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.96,"clarityScore":2.87,"evidenceConfidence":0.47,"clarityConfidence":0.88,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:22.319Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.22,0.5,0.25],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.1,0.89]}},"durationMs":96,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0.47,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"13.9 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"47% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 2.0/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0336","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.68,"evidenceScore":2.48,"clarityScore":2.74,"evidenceConfidence":0.48,"clarityConfidence":0.75,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:22.559Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.16,0.17,0.66],"clarity":[0.07,0.01,0.02,0.9]}},"durationMs":86,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":200,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €200.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0337","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.63,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.25,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:22.792Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.12,0.32,0.37,0.19],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.25,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"8 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"25% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.6/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0338","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.24,"clarityScore":0.09,"evidenceConfidence":0.78,"clarityConfidence":0.92,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:23.038Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.78,0.22,0,0],"clarity":[0.92,0.08,0,0]}},"durationMs":91,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0339","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":2.03,"clarityScore":2.91,"evidenceConfidence":0.44,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:23.269Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.19,0.48,0.29],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.07,0.92]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0.44,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"180 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"44% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 2.0/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 90%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0340","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"crew","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.38,"clarityScore":2.69,"evidenceConfidence":0.51,"clarityConfidence":0.7,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:23.515Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.52,0.41,0.01],"clarity":[0,0,0.3,0.7]}},"durationMs":92,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0341","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.9,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.9,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:23.748Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.9,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0342","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.55,"clarityScore":2.99,"evidenceConfidence":0.25,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:23.978Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.13,0.34,0.38,0.15],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0343","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.81,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.81,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:24.208Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.19,0.81,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":76,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0344","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.82,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.81,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:24.447Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.19,0.81,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":87,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0345","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.27,"clarityScore":0.1,"evidenceConfidence":0.75,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:24.707Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.75,0.25,0,0],"clarity":[0.9,0.1,0,0]}},"durationMs":102,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0346","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.81,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.81,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:24.938Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.19,0.81,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.81,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"0 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"81% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0347","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.98,"clarityScore":2.91,"evidenceConfidence":0.47,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:25.191Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.2,0.51,0.25],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.07,0.92]}},"durationMs":88,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.47,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"181 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"47% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 2.0/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0348","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.82,"clarityScore":0.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.82,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:25.422Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.18,0.82,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0349","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.91,"clarityScore":2.87,"evidenceConfidence":0.42,"clarityConfidence":0.88,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:25.690Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.24,0.47,0.24],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.1,0.89]}},"durationMs":114,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0350","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.83,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.83,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:25.925Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.17,0.83,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.83,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"0 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"83% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0351","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.68,"evidenceScore":2.44,"clarityScore":2.77,"evidenceConfidence":0.45,"clarityConfidence":0.75,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:26.173Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.16,0.2,0.63],"clarity":[0.07,0.01,0.02,0.9]}},"durationMs":94,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0352","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.51,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.27,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:26.407Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.11,0.4,0.36,0.13],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0353","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.67,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.66,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:26.648Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.07,0.17,0.75],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.66,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"239 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"96% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"66% conservative judgment strength; 98% denial threshold. Evidence 2.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 98%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0354","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.66,"evidenceScore":2.47,"clarityScore":2.75,"evidenceConfidence":0.47,"clarityConfidence":0.74,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:26.879Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.16,0.18,0.65],"clarity":[0.07,0.01,0.03,0.89]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0355","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.62,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.28,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:27.110Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.11,0.33,0.39,0.17],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0356","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.66,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.66,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:27.352Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.34,0.66,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":88,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0357","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.97,"clarityScore":2.9,"evidenceConfidence":0.47,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:27.613Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.22,0.5,0.25],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.08,0.91]}},"durationMs":138,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.47,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"180 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"47% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 2.0/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0358","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.02,"clarityScore":0.55,"evidenceConfidence":0.97,"clarityConfidence":0.46,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:27.877Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.97,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.73,0.08,0.11,0.08]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0359","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.73,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.72,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:28.112Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.05,0.15,0.79],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0.72,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"0 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"96% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"72% conservative judgment strength; 98% denial threshold. Evidence 2.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 98%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0360","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.74,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.75,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:28.349Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.05,0.15,0.8],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":83,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.75,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"180 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"96% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"75% conservative judgment strength; 98% denial threshold. Evidence 2.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 98%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0361","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.7,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.7,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:28.594Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.05,0.17,0.77],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":93,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0362","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.51,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.25,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:28.833Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.13,0.36,0.38,0.13],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":85,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0363","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.73,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.73,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:29.063Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.27,0.73,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":75,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"119 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 119 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0364","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.89,"clarityScore":0.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.89,"clarityConfidence":0.98,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:29.303Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.11,0.89,0,0],"clarity":[0.98,0.02,0,0]}},"durationMs":85,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":250,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €250.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0365","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.84,"clarityScore":2.89,"evidenceConfidence":0.43,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:29.556Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.26,0.48,0.21],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.08,0.91]}},"durationMs":95,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0366","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"crew","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.22,"clarityScore":2.66,"evidenceConfidence":0.56,"clarityConfidence":0.66,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:29.784Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.11,0.57,0.31,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.32,0.67]}},"durationMs":75,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0367","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.4,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.33,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:30.017Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.14,0.43,0.33,0.1],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0368","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.37,"clarityScore":0.15,"evidenceConfidence":0.64,"clarityConfidence":0.85,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:30.250Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.64,0.36,0,0],"clarity":[0.85,0.15,0,0]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0369","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.35,"clarityScore":0.13,"evidenceConfidence":0.65,"clarityConfidence":0.87,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:30.581Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.65,0.35,0,0],"clarity":[0.87,0.13,0,0]}},"durationMs":178,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"179 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 179 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0370","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.81,"clarityScore":0.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.81,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:30.812Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.19,0.81,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0371","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.02,"clarityScore":0.58,"evidenceConfidence":0.96,"clarityConfidence":0.44,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:31.048Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.96,0.03,0],"clarity":[0.72,0.08,0.12,0.08]}},"durationMs":88,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.44,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"13 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"44% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.0/3, clarity 0.6/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0372","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.18,"clarityScore":0.09,"evidenceConfidence":0.82,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:31.282Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.82,0.18,0,0],"clarity":[0.91,0.09,0,0]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0373","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.92,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.92,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:31.531Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.08,0.92,0,0],"clarity":[1,0,0,0]}},"durationMs":96,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0374","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.89,"clarityScore":0.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.89,"clarityConfidence":0.98,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:31.764Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.11,0.89,0,0],"clarity":[0.98,0.02,0,0]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":200,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €200.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0375","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.23,"clarityScore":0.09,"evidenceConfidence":0.78,"clarityConfidence":0.92,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:32.004Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.78,0.22,0,0],"clarity":[0.92,0.08,0,0]}},"durationMs":87,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0376","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.82,"clarityScore":2.82,"evidenceConfidence":0.4,"clarityConfidence":0.83,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:32.237Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.29,0.45,0.21],"clarity":[0.02,0.02,0.07,0.89]}},"durationMs":76,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0377","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"weather","evidence":"partial","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.42,"evidenceScore":1.94,"clarityScore":2.91,"evidenceConfidence":0.69,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:32.500Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.18,0.6900000000000001,0.13],"clarity":[0,0,0.09,0.91]}},"durationMs":110,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0378","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.33,"clarityScore":0.14,"evidenceConfidence":0.67,"clarityConfidence":0.86,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:32.774Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.67,0.33,0,0],"clarity":[0.86,0.14,0,0]}},"durationMs":121,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.67,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6.9 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"67% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.3/3, clarity 0.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0379","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.48,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.24,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:33.024Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.14,0.37,0.36,0.13],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":100,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0380","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.63,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.3,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:33.285Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.11,0.32,0.41,0.16],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":106,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.3,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"240 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"30% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.6/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0381","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.79,"clarityScore":2.78,"evidenceConfidence":0.39,"clarityConfidence":0.77,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:33.517Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.29,0.45,0.2],"clarity":[0.03,0.03,0.08,0.86]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0382","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.69,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.69,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:33.750Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.31,0.69,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0.69,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"181 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"69% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.7/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 240 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0383","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.82,"clarityScore":2.76,"evidenceConfidence":0.39,"clarityConfidence":0.76,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:33.979Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.3,0.44,0.21],"clarity":[0.03,0.03,0.09,0.85]}},"durationMs":146,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0384","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.2,"clarityScore":0.09,"evidenceConfidence":0.81,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:34.283Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.81,0.19,0,0],"clarity":[0.91,0.09,0,0]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0385","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.8,"clarityScore":0.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.8,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:34.541Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.2,0.8,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":105,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0386","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"weather","evidence":"partial","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.48,"evidenceScore":1.99,"clarityScore":2.93,"evidenceConfidence":0.66,"clarityConfidence":0.93,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:34.783Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.17,0.66,0.17],"clarity":[0,0,0.07,0.93]}},"durationMs":86,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.52,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"0 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"48% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"52% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 2.0/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0387","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.77,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.76,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:35.014Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.24,0.76,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0388","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"weather","evidence":"partial","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.18,"evidenceScore":1.71,"clarityScore":2.57,"evidenceConfidence":0.51,"clarityConfidence":0.55,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:35.264Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.37,0.52,0.1],"clarity":[0.1,0.02,0.11,0.77]}},"durationMs":98,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":200,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €200.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0389","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.92,"clarityScore":0,"evidenceConfidence":0.92,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:35.530Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.08,0.92,0,0],"clarity":[1,0,0,0]}},"durationMs":109,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0390","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.71,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.71,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:35.775Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.29,0.71,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":90,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.71,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"71% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.7/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0391","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.79,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.32,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:36.017Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.09,0.27,0.41,0.23],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":89,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.32,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"13.9 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"32% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.8/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0392","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.86,"clarityScore":2.87,"evidenceConfidence":0.44,"clarityConfidence":0.89,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:36.276Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.25,0.49,0.21],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.09,0.9]}},"durationMs":107,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0393","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.45,"clarityScore":2.35,"evidenceConfidence":0.47,"clarityConfidence":0.54,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:36.507Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.48,0.47,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.05,0.54,0.41]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0394","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.88,"clarityScore":0.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.88,"clarityConfidence":0.98,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:36.785Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.12,0.88,0,0],"clarity":[0.98,0.02,0,0]}},"durationMs":124,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0395","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.97,"clarityScore":2.88,"evidenceConfidence":0.49,"clarityConfidence":0.89,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:37.014Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.21,0.52,0.24],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.09,0.9]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0396","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.68,"evidenceScore":2.52,"clarityScore":2.88,"evidenceConfidence":0.53,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:37.268Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.13,0.18,0.68],"clarity":[0.03,0,0.01,0.96]}},"durationMs":101,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0397","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"crew","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.01,"clarityScore":0.91,"evidenceConfidence":0.96,"clarityConfidence":0.08,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:37.508Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.02,0.96,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.61,0.03,0.19,0.17]}},"durationMs":86,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0398","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.76,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.78,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:37.741Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.04,0.14,0.81],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0399","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.8,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.8,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:37.970Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.2,0.8,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0400","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"crew","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1,"clarityScore":1.06,"evidenceConfidence":0.95,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:38.292Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.95,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.56,0.03,0.21,0.2]}},"durationMs":168,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"239 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"0% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.0/3, clarity 1.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0401","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.82,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.82,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:38.525Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.18,0.82,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":97,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.82,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"181 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"82% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0402","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.21,"evidenceScore":1.12,"clarityScore":1.33,"evidenceConfidence":0.87,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:38.807Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.9,0.06,0.03],"clarity":[0.5,0.02,0.13,0.35]}},"durationMs":109,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0403","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.8,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.8,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:39.039Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.2,0.8,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0404","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.94,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.94,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:39.278Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.94,0,0],"clarity":[1,0,0,0]}},"durationMs":86,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.94,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"181 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"94% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.9/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0405","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.26,"evidenceScore":1.13,"clarityScore":1.44,"evidenceConfidence":0.87,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:39.531Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.9,0.07,0.03],"clarity":[0.47,0.01,0.13,0.39]}},"durationMs":99,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0406","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.59,"clarityScore":2.99,"evidenceConfidence":0.28,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:39.761Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.12,0.32,0.4,0.16],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.28,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"240 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"28% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.6/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0407","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.23,"clarityScore":0.11,"evidenceConfidence":0.78,"clarityConfidence":0.89,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:40.053Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.78,0.22,0,0],"clarity":[0.89,0.11,0,0]}},"durationMs":112,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0408","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.78,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.79,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:40.300Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.04,0.13,0.83],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":83,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.79,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"181 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"96% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"79% conservative judgment strength; 98% denial threshold. Evidence 2.8/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 98%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0409","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"crew","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.01,"clarityScore":1.06,"evidenceConfidence":0.96,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:40.586Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.02,0.96,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.56,0.02,0.21,0.2]}},"durationMs":129,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"0 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"0% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.0/3, clarity 1.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0410","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.87,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.33,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:40.824Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.08,0.24,0.41000000000000003,0.27],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":84,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0411","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.82,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.81,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:41.103Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.19,0.81,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":125,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"119 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 119 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0412","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.41,"evidenceScore":1.09,"clarityScore":1.49,"evidenceConfidence":0.91,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:41.359Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.93,0.05,0.02],"clarity":[0.44,0.01,0.18,0.37]}},"durationMs":98,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"239 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"41% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"0% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.1/3, clarity 1.5/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0413","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.8,"clarityScore":2.78,"evidenceConfidence":0.39,"clarityConfidence":0.76,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:41.592Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.29,0.45,0.2],"clarity":[0.03,0.03,0.09,0.85]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0414","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":2.01,"clarityScore":2.87,"evidenceConfidence":0.46,"clarityConfidence":0.88,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:41.820Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.19,0.5,0.27],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.1,0.89]}},"durationMs":75,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.46,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"8 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"46% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 2.0/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 90%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0415","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.68,"clarityScore":2.99,"evidenceConfidence":0.25,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:42.068Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.12,0.3,0.37,0.21],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":97,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0416","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.24,"clarityScore":0.09,"evidenceConfidence":0.77,"clarityConfidence":0.92,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:42.352Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.77,0.23,0,0],"clarity":[0.92,0.08,0,0]}},"durationMs":124,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0417","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.65,"clarityScore":2.99,"evidenceConfidence":0.28,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:42.621Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.11,0.31,0.39,0.19],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":119,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.28,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"8 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"28% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.6/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0418","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.82,"clarityScore":2.88,"evidenceConfidence":0.41,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:42.886Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.27,0.47,0.2],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.08,0.91]}},"durationMs":235,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0419","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.69,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.69,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:43.253Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.31,0.69,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":84,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0420","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.61,"clarityScore":2.99,"evidenceConfidence":0.28,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:43.483Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.11,0.33,0.39,0.17],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.28,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"360 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"28% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.6/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0421","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.24,"clarityScore":0.1,"evidenceConfidence":0.77,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:43.731Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.77,0.23,0,0],"clarity":[0.91,0.09,0,0]}},"durationMs":94,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":200,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €200.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0422","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.38,"clarityScore":2.24,"evidenceConfidence":0.56,"clarityConfidence":0.49,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:43.960Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.57,0.39,0.01],"clarity":[0.01,0.12,0.5,0.37]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0423","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.69,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.67,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:44.263Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.06,0.18,0.75],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":115,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"119 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 119 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0424","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.83,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.82,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:44.505Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.18,0.82,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":85,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"179 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 179 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0425","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.94,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.94,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:44.752Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.94,0,0],"clarity":[1,0,0,0]}},"durationMs":95,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0426","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.92,"clarityScore":2.81,"evidenceConfidence":0.43,"clarityConfidence":0.82,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:44.994Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.25,0.47,0.24],"clarity":[0.02,0.02,0.08,0.88]}},"durationMs":83,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0427","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.2,"clarityScore":0.12,"evidenceConfidence":0.8,"clarityConfidence":0.89,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:45.240Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.8,0.2,0,0],"clarity":[0.89,0.11,0,0]}},"durationMs":89,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0428","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.97,"clarityScore":2.91,"evidenceConfidence":0.47,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:45.488Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.2,0.51,0.25],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.07,0.92]}},"durationMs":93,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.47,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"240 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"47% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 2.0/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0429","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.8,"clarityScore":0.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.8,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:45.732Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.2,0.8,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":90,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0430","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.47,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.28,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:45.989Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.13,0.4,0.35,0.12],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":104,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0431","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"crew","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.98,"clarityScore":1.17,"evidenceConfidence":0.94,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:46.225Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.94,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.53,0.02,0.2,0.25]}},"durationMs":134,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0432","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.26,"clarityScore":0.1,"evidenceConfidence":0.75,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:46.529Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.75,0.25,0,0],"clarity":[0.91,0.09,0,0]}},"durationMs":97,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":200,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €200.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0433","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.22,"clarityScore":0.1,"evidenceConfidence":0.79,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:46.761Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.79,0.21,0,0],"clarity":[0.91,0.09,0,0]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.79,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"13.9 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"79% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.2/3, clarity 0.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0434","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.26,"clarityScore":0.11,"evidenceConfidence":0.75,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:47.009Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.75,0.25,0,0],"clarity":[0.9,0.1,0,0]}},"durationMs":96,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":250,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €250.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0435","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.74,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.72,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:47.251Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.05,0.15,0.79],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"179 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 179 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0436","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.68,"clarityScore":2.73,"evidenceConfidence":0.36,"clarityConfidence":0.73,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:47.510Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.07,0.34,0.43,0.16],"clarity":[0.04,0.03,0.09,0.84]}},"durationMs":104,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0437","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.81,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.81,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:47.773Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.19,0.81,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":90,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.81,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6.9 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"81% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0438","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.05,"clarityScore":0.9,"evidenceConfidence":0.96,"clarityConfidence":0.08,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:48.011Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.96,0.04,0],"clarity":[0.57,0.09,0.19,0.15]}},"durationMs":87,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"179 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 179 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0439","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"crew","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1,"clarityScore":1.07,"evidenceConfidence":0.96,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:48.243Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.02,0.96,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.55,0.02,0.22,0.2]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6.9 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"0% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.0/3, clarity 1.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0440","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.77,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.77,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:48.481Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.23,0.77,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":86,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0441","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.66,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.66,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:48.748Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.34,0.66,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":114,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0442","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.93,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.93,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:48.990Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.07,0.93,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":159,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.93,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"240 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"93% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.9/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0443","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.23,"clarityScore":0.1,"evidenceConfidence":0.77,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:49.305Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.77,0.23,0,0],"clarity":[0.91,0.09,0,0]}},"durationMs":75,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0444","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.52,"clarityScore":2.36,"evidenceConfidence":0.5,"clarityConfidence":0.54,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:49.553Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.02,0.45,0.52,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.05,0.54,0.41]}},"durationMs":96,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.5,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"8 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"50% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.5/3, clarity 2.4/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0445","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.97,"evidenceScore":2.69,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.68,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:49.784Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.06,0.17,0.76],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0446","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.82,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.81,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:50.037Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.19,0.81,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":101,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"179 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 179 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0447","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.23,"clarityScore":0.11,"evidenceConfidence":0.78,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:50.276Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.78,0.22,0,0],"clarity":[0.9,0.1,0,0]}},"durationMs":86,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":600,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €600; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €600.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0448","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.35,"clarityScore":0.15,"evidenceConfidence":0.66,"clarityConfidence":0.85,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:50.510Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.66,0.34,0,0],"clarity":[0.85,0.15,0,0]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.66,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"0 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"66% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.3/3, clarity 0.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0449","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.89,"clarityScore":2.87,"evidenceConfidence":0.44,"clarityConfidence":0.89,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:50.759Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.25,0.48,0.23],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.09,0.9]}},"durationMs":94,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.44,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"0 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"44% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.9/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0450","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"weather","evidence":"partial","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.41,"evidenceScore":2,"clarityScore":2.91,"evidenceConfidence":0.66,"clarityConfidence":0.92,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:51.000Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.17,0.66,0.17],"clarity":[0,0,0.08,0.92]}},"durationMs":89,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.5900000000000001,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"0 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"41% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"59% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 2.0/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 90%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0451","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.92,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.92,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:51.251Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.08,0.92,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":96,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.92,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"180 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"92% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.9/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0452","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.65,"evidenceScore":2.39,"clarityScore":2.75,"evidenceConfidence":0.4,"clarityConfidence":0.75,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:51.488Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.18,0.21,0.6],"clarity":[0.07,0.01,0.02,0.9]}},"durationMs":86,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0453","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.21,"clarityScore":0.11,"evidenceConfidence":0.8,"clarityConfidence":0.89,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:51.748Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.8,0.2,0,0],"clarity":[0.89,0.11,0,0]}},"durationMs":113,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.8,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"240 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"80% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.2/3, clarity 0.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0454","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"crew","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.26,"clarityScore":2.64,"evidenceConfidence":0.57,"clarityConfidence":0.65,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:52.002Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.08,0.58,0.33,0.01],"clarity":[0,0,0.35,0.65]}},"durationMs":99,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0455","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"crew","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.32,"clarityScore":2.64,"evidenceConfidence":0.53,"clarityConfidence":0.65,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:52.233Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.07,0.54,0.38,0.01],"clarity":[0,0,0.35,0.65]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.53,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"239 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"53% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.3/3, clarity 2.6/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0456","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.82,"clarityScore":0.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.82,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:52.467Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.18,0.82,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.82,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"181 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"82% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0457","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.7,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.7,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:52.713Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.3,0.7,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":94,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.7,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"13.9 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"70% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.7/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0458","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.6,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.6,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:52.943Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.4,0.6,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0459","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.84,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.84,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:53.172Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.16,0.84,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"179 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 179 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0460","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.39,"clarityScore":0.15,"evidenceConfidence":0.61,"clarityConfidence":0.85,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:53.412Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.61,0.39,0,0],"clarity":[0.85,0.15,0,0]}},"durationMs":89,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.61,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"241 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"61% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.4/3, clarity 0.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0461","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.56,"clarityScore":2.44,"evidenceConfidence":0.54,"clarityConfidence":0.52,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:53.654Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.02,0.41,0.56,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.02,0.52,0.46]}},"durationMs":85,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.52,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"240 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"52% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.6/3, clarity 2.4/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0462","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1,"clarityScore":0.49,"evidenceConfidence":0.96,"clarityConfidence":0.51,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:53.926Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.02,0.96,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.76,0.07,0.09,0.08]}},"durationMs":120,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0463","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.71,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.7,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:54.159Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.05,0.17,0.77],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0464","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.92,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.92,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:54.393Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.08,0.92,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":125,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €125.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0465","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"crew","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.24,"clarityScore":2.62,"evidenceConfidence":0.57,"clarityConfidence":0.62,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:54.624Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.09,0.58,0.32,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.36,0.63]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0466","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.25,"evidenceScore":1.11,"clarityScore":1.34,"evidenceConfidence":0.88,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:54.862Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.91,0.05,0.03],"clarity":[0.5,0.02,0.12,0.36]}},"durationMs":85,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":250,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €250.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0467","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.18,"clarityScore":0.12,"evidenceConfidence":0.82,"clarityConfidence":0.89,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:55.095Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.82,0.18,0,0],"clarity":[0.89,0.11,0,0]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0.82,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"240 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"82% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.2/3, clarity 0.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 240 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0468","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.74,"clarityScore":2.71,"evidenceConfidence":0.41,"clarityConfidence":0.7,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:55.330Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.3,0.47000000000000003,0.17],"clarity":[0.05,0.03,0.09,0.83]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":200,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €200.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0469","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.78,"clarityScore":0.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.78,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:55.576Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.22,0.78,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":120,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.78,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"78% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0470","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.2,"clarityScore":0.1,"evidenceConfidence":0.81,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:55.833Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.81,0.19,0,0],"clarity":[0.9,0.1,0,0]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.81,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"240 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"81% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.2/3, clarity 0.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0471","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.02,"clarityScore":0.64,"evidenceConfidence":0.97,"clarityConfidence":0.36,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:56.067Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.97,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.7,0.06,0.14,0.1]}},"durationMs":83,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0472","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"crew","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.98,"clarityScore":1.1,"evidenceConfidence":0.94,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:56.315Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.94,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.54,0.03,0.21,0.22]}},"durationMs":96,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0473","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.52,"clarityScore":2.42,"evidenceConfidence":0.48,"clarityConfidence":0.5,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:56.549Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.44,0.51,0.02],"clarity":[0,0.04,0.5,0.46]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.48,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"241 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"48% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.5/3, clarity 2.4/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0474","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.9,"clarityScore":2.9,"evidenceConfidence":0.4,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:56.788Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.07,0.21,0.47,0.25],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.07,0.92]}},"durationMs":86,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0475","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"crew","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.01,"clarityScore":1.05,"evidenceConfidence":0.96,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:57.088Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.02,0.96,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.55,0.03,0.22,0.2]}},"durationMs":148,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"119 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 119 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0476","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.68,"evidenceScore":2.46,"clarityScore":2.78,"evidenceConfidence":0.46,"clarityConfidence":0.78,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:57.323Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.16,0.19,0.64],"clarity":[0.06,0.01,0.02,0.91]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0477","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.69,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.29,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:57.578Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.11,0.29,0.4,0.2],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":98,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.29,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"13 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"29% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0478","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.67,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.28,"clarityConfidence":0.98,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:57.808Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.12,0.29,0.39999999999999997,0.19],"clarity":[0,0,0.02,0.98]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.28,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"28% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0479","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.25,"clarityScore":0.12,"evidenceConfidence":0.76,"clarityConfidence":0.89,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:58.061Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.76,0.24,0,0],"clarity":[0.89,0.11,0,0]}},"durationMs":103,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.76,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"241 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"76% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.3/3, clarity 0.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0480","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.86,"clarityScore":2.87,"evidenceConfidence":0.4,"clarityConfidence":0.87,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:58.308Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.07,0.23,0.47,0.23],"clarity":[0,0.02,0.09,0.89]}},"durationMs":95,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0481","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.52,"clarityScore":2.99,"evidenceConfidence":0.24,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:58.543Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.12,0.38,0.36,0.14],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":148,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":200,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €200.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0482","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.19,"clarityScore":0.09,"evidenceConfidence":0.82,"clarityConfidence":0.92,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:58.844Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.82,0.18,0,0],"clarity":[0.92,0.08,0,0]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":200,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €200.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0483","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.7,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.7,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:59.069Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.3,0.7,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":73,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.7,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"8 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"70% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.7/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0484","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.45,"clarityScore":2.39,"evidenceConfidence":0.5,"clarityConfidence":0.52,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:59.307Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.51,0.45,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.04,0.52,0.44]}},"durationMs":87,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.5,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"13 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"50% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.4/3, clarity 2.4/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0485","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.4,"evidenceScore":1.07,"clarityScore":1.6,"evidenceConfidence":0.92,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:59.540Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.94,0.04,0.02],"clarity":[0.4,0.01,0.18,0.41]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0486","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.01,"clarityScore":0.51,"evidenceConfidence":0.96,"clarityConfidence":0.49,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:33:59.773Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.02,0.96,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.75,0.08,0.08,0.09]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0487","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.74,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.76,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:00.008Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.05,0.14,0.8],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.76,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"180 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"96% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"76% conservative judgment strength; 98% denial threshold. Evidence 2.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 98%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0488","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.49,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.25,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:00.239Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.13,0.38,0.36,0.13],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":75,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0489","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.4,"evidenceScore":1.08,"clarityScore":1.51,"evidenceConfidence":0.92,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:00.484Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.94,0.04,0.02],"clarity":[0.43,0.01,0.18,0.38]}},"durationMs":95,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"119 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 119 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0490","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.88,"clarityScore":2.83,"evidenceConfidence":0.44,"clarityConfidence":0.83,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:00.719Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.26,0.48,0.22],"clarity":[0.02,0.02,0.07,0.89]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0491","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"crew","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1,"clarityScore":1.06,"evidenceConfidence":0.95,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:00.972Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.95,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.57,0.02,0.19,0.22]}},"durationMs":96,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":250,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €250.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0492","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.78,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.79,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:01.207Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.04,0.13,0.83],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":83,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.79,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"181 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"96% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"79% conservative judgment strength; 98% denial threshold. Evidence 2.8/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 98%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0493","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.89,"clarityScore":2.87,"evidenceConfidence":0.43,"clarityConfidence":0.89,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:01.443Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.24,0.48,0.23],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.09,0.9]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0494","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.8,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.8,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:01.686Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.2,0.8,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":91,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":300,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €600; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €300.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0495","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.96,"evidenceScore":2.71,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.69,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:01.923Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.06,0.16,0.77],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":84,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.69,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"239 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"96% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"69% conservative judgment strength; 98% denial threshold. Evidence 2.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 98%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0496","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.94,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.94,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:02.215Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.94,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":136,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.94,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"240 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"94% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.9/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0497","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.75,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.33,"clarityConfidence":0.98,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:02.494Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.09,0.28,0.42,0.21],"clarity":[0,0,0.02,0.98]}},"durationMs":128,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.33,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"33% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.8/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0498","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"weather","evidence":"partial","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.5,"evidenceScore":1.98,"clarityScore":2.92,"evidenceConfidence":0.65,"clarityConfidence":0.92,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:02.751Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.18,0.65,0.17],"clarity":[0,0,0.08,0.92]}},"durationMs":106,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0499","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":2.04,"clarityScore":2.92,"evidenceConfidence":0.47,"clarityConfidence":0.92,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:02.986Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.18,0.5,0.29],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.06,0.93]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.47,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"241 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"47% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 2.0/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 90%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0500","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.95,"evidenceScore":2.77,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.78,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:03.222Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.04,0.14,0.82],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0501","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.25,"evidenceScore":1.11,"clarityScore":1.26,"evidenceConfidence":0.88,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:03.455Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.91,0.06,0.03],"clarity":[0.53,0.01,0.12,0.34]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0502","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.72,"evidenceScore":2.51,"clarityScore":2.8,"evidenceConfidence":0.52,"clarityConfidence":0.78,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:03.693Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.14,0.17,0.67],"clarity":[0.06,0.01,0.02,0.91]}},"durationMs":89,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":125,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €125.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0503","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.8,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.79,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:03.930Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.21,0.79,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0504","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"crew","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.26,"clarityScore":2.68,"evidenceConfidence":0.57,"clarityConfidence":0.69,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:04.176Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.08,0.58,0.33,0.01],"clarity":[0,0,0.31,0.69]}},"durationMs":95,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.57,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"181 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"57% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.3/3, clarity 2.7/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0505","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.92,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.92,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:04.407Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.08,0.92,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.92,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"180 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"92% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.9/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0506","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.83,"clarityScore":0.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.83,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:04.644Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.17,0.83,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":84,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.83,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"83% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0507","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.78,"clarityScore":2.76,"evidenceConfidence":0.4,"clarityConfidence":0.75,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:04.906Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.31,0.45,0.19],"clarity":[0.04,0.03,0.07,0.86]}},"durationMs":107,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0508","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.97,"evidenceScore":2.74,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.72,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:05.142Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.05,0.15,0.79],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":87,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0509","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.73,"evidenceScore":2.54,"clarityScore":2.83,"evidenceConfidence":0.54,"clarityConfidence":0.81,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:05.375Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.13,0.17,0.69],"clarity":[0.05,0.01,0.02,0.92]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0510","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.61,"clarityScore":2.99,"evidenceConfidence":0.27,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:05.616Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.11,0.34,0.38,0.17],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":88,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0511","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.23,"clarityScore":0.13,"evidenceConfidence":0.78,"clarityConfidence":0.88,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:05.849Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.78,0.22,0,0],"clarity":[0.88,0.12,0,0]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0512","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.92,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.92,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:06.082Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.08,0.92,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"179 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 179 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0513","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.73,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.73,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:06.328Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.27,0.73,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":91,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.73,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"241 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"73% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.7/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0514","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.83,"clarityScore":2.78,"evidenceConfidence":0.41,"clarityConfidence":0.76,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:06.576Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.3,0.45,0.21],"clarity":[0.03,0.03,0.09,0.85]}},"durationMs":94,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0515","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"crew","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.23,"clarityScore":2.66,"evidenceConfidence":0.57,"clarityConfidence":0.66,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:06.810Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.58,0.31,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.32,0.67]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0516","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"crew","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.35,"clarityScore":2.64,"evidenceConfidence":0.51,"clarityConfidence":0.63,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:07.047Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.07,0.52,0.4,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.35,0.64]}},"durationMs":83,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0517","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.19,"clarityScore":0.09,"evidenceConfidence":0.81,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:07.276Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.81,0.19,0,0],"clarity":[0.91,0.09,0,0]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0518","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.9,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.9,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:07.523Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.9,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":91,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.9,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"241 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"90% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.9/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0519","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.2,"clarityScore":0.12,"evidenceConfidence":0.8,"clarityConfidence":0.88,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:07.761Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.8,0.2,0,0],"clarity":[0.88,0.12,0,0]}},"durationMs":84,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.8,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"80% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.2/3, clarity 0.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0520","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.76,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.27,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:07.996Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.11,0.27,0.38,0.24],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.27,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"0 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"27% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.8/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0521","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.82,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.81,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:08.236Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.19,0.81,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":87,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0522","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.24,"clarityScore":0.1,"evidenceConfidence":0.77,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:08.472Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.77,0.23,0,0],"clarity":[0.9,0.1,0,0]}},"durationMs":83,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0523","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.02,"clarityScore":0.48,"evidenceConfidence":0.95,"clarityConfidence":0.53,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:08.704Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.02,0.95,0.03,0],"clarity":[0.77,0.07,0.08,0.08]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":200,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €200.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0524","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.97,"evidenceScore":2.75,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.73,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:08.944Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.05,0.14,0.8],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":89,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0525","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.56,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.26,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:09.194Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.12,0.35,0.38,0.15],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":93,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"179 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 179 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0526","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.39,"clarityScore":0.12,"evidenceConfidence":0.62,"clarityConfidence":0.88,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:09.432Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.62,0.38,0,0],"clarity":[0.88,0.12,0,0]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0527","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.92,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.92,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:09.662Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.08,0.92,0,0],"clarity":[1,0,0,0]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0528","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.93,"clarityScore":2.88,"evidenceConfidence":0.44,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:09.897Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.23,0.48,0.25],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.08,0.91]}},"durationMs":86,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0529","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"crew","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1,"clarityScore":1.07,"evidenceConfidence":0.96,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:10.138Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.02,0.96,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.55,0.03,0.21,0.21]}},"durationMs":103,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"181 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"0% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.0/3, clarity 1.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0530","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.42,"evidenceScore":1.09,"clarityScore":1.61,"evidenceConfidence":0.91,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:10.390Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.93,0.05,0.02],"clarity":[0.4,0.01,0.18,0.41]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"179 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 179 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0531","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.21,"clarityScore":0.11,"evidenceConfidence":0.8,"clarityConfidence":0.89,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:10.622Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.8,0.2,0,0],"clarity":[0.89,0.11,0,0]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0532","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.33,"clarityScore":0.14,"evidenceConfidence":0.67,"clarityConfidence":0.87,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:10.868Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.67,0.33,0,0],"clarity":[0.87,0.13,0,0]}},"durationMs":93,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0533","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.7,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.7,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:11.106Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.3,0.7,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":84,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.7,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"239 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"70% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.7/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0534","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"crew","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.01,"clarityScore":0.95,"evidenceConfidence":0.96,"clarityConfidence":0.06,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:11.342Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.02,0.96,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.6,0.03,0.2,0.17]}},"durationMs":84,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.06,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6.9 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"6% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.0/3, clarity 0.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0535","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.84,"clarityScore":2.74,"evidenceConfidence":0.45,"clarityConfidence":0.75,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:11.576Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.28,0.49,0.19],"clarity":[0.03,0.03,0.1,0.84]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":250,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €250.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0536","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"weather","evidence":"partial","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.46,"evidenceScore":1.99,"clarityScore":2.91,"evidenceConfidence":0.67,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:11.804Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.17,0.67,0.16],"clarity":[0,0,0.09,0.91]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.54,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"239 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"46% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"54% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 2.0/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0537","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.23,"clarityScore":0.1,"evidenceConfidence":0.78,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:12.050Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.78,0.22,0,0],"clarity":[0.91,0.09,0,0]}},"durationMs":92,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":250,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €250.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0538","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.78,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.78,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:12.282Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.22,0.78,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":200,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €200.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0539","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.61,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.28,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:12.555Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.11,0.33,0.39,0.17],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":121,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0.28,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"181 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"28% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.6/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 240 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0540","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.68,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.68,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:12.789Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.32,0.68,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0541","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"crew","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.25,"clarityScore":2.66,"evidenceConfidence":0.55,"clarityConfidence":0.66,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:13.038Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.56,0.33,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.32,0.67]}},"durationMs":96,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":200,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €200.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0542","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.97,"evidenceScore":2.78,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.79,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:13.274Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.04,0.13,0.83],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.79,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"180 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"97% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"79% conservative judgment strength; 98% denial threshold. Evidence 2.8/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 98%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0543","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.92,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.92,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:13.546Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.08,0.92,0,0],"clarity":[1,0,0,0]}},"durationMs":111,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0544","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.93,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.93,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:13.798Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.07,0.93,0,0],"clarity":[1,0,0,0]}},"durationMs":99,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.93,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"239 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"93% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.9/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0545","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.79,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.78,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:14.029Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.22,0.78,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":83,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0546","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.95,"evidenceScore":2.75,"clarityScore":2.99,"evidenceConfidence":0.75,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:14.307Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.04,0.14,0.81],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":122,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.75,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"181 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"95% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"75% conservative judgment strength; 98% denial threshold. Evidence 2.8/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 98%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0547","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.79,"clarityScore":2.8,"evidenceConfidence":0.42,"clarityConfidence":0.82,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:14.541Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.31,0.46,0.19],"clarity":[0.02,0.02,0.08,0.88]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0548","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.62,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.27,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:14.777Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.35,0.37,0.18],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":83,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.27,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"180 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"27% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.6/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0549","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.67,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.67,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:15.033Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.33,0.67,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":95,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"<7 days notice; replacement departs ≤1 hour early and arrives <2 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"<7 days notice; replacement departs ≤1 hour early and arrives <2 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0550","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.36,"clarityScore":0.18,"evidenceConfidence":0.64,"clarityConfidence":0.83,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:15.323Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.64,0.36,0,0],"clarity":[0.83,0.17,0,0]}},"durationMs":132,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.64,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"360 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"64% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.4/3, clarity 0.2/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0551","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"crew","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.17,"clarityScore":2.67,"evidenceConfidence":0.62,"clarityConfidence":0.67,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:15.560Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.63,0.26,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.31,0.68]}},"durationMs":83,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0552","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.91,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.9,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:15.793Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.9,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0.9,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6.9 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"90% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.9/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0553","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"crew","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.01,"clarityScore":1.06,"evidenceConfidence":0.96,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:16.033Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.02,0.96,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.56,0.03,0.2,0.21]}},"durationMs":88,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"8 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"0% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.0/3, clarity 1.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0554","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.67,"clarityScore":2.99,"evidenceConfidence":0.3,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:16.262Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.31,0.4,0.19],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":76,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.3,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"181 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"30% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0555","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.87,"clarityScore":2.91,"evidenceConfidence":0.42,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:16.525Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.24,0.48,0.22],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.07,0.92]}},"durationMs":110,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0.42,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"241 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"42% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.9/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 240 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0556","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.23,"clarityScore":0.1,"evidenceConfidence":0.78,"clarityConfidence":0.91,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:16.786Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.78,0.22,0,0],"clarity":[0.91,0.09,0,0]}},"durationMs":108,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0557","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":2.02,"clarityScore":2.93,"evidenceConfidence":0.47,"clarityConfidence":0.92,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:17.021Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.03,0.19,0.5,0.28],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.06,0.9299999999999999]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.47,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"240 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"47% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 2.0/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 90%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0558","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.92,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.92,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:17.252Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.08,0.92,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":76,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":200,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €200.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0559","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.79,"clarityScore":2.76,"evidenceConfidence":0.4,"clarityConfidence":0.74,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:17.481Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.3,0.45,0.2],"clarity":[0.03,0.04,0.09,0.84]}},"durationMs":75,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0560","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.71,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.71,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:17.735Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.29,0.71,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.71,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"181 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"71% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.7/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0561","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.67,"clarityScore":2.99,"evidenceConfidence":0.3,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:17.966Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.32,0.4,0.18],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"179 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 179 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0562","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.65,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.29,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:18.229Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.11,0.31,0.39999999999999997,0.18],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":107,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.29,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"181 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"29% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.6/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0563","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.97,"evidenceScore":2.72,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.7,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:18.462Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.05,0.17,0.77],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":80,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.7,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6.9 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"97% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"70% conservative judgment strength; 98% denial threshold. Evidence 2.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 98%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0564","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.24,"clarityScore":0.11,"evidenceConfidence":0.77,"clarityConfidence":0.9,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:18.695Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.77,0.23,0,0],"clarity":[0.9,0.1,0,0]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0565","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.65,"clarityScore":2.99,"evidenceConfidence":0.27,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:18.926Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.12,0.3,0.39,0.19],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":79,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.27,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"27% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.6/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0566","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.95,"evidenceScore":2.74,"clarityScore":3,"evidenceConfidence":0.75,"clarityConfidence":1,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:19.182Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.05,0.15,0.8],"clarity":[0,0,0,1]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"119 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 119 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0567","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.92,"clarityScore":2.92,"evidenceConfidence":0.42,"clarityConfidence":0.92,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:19.412Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.23,0.47,0.25],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.06,0.93]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.42,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"360 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"42% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.9/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0568","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.78,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.78,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:19.636Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.22,0.78,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":72,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0569","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.68,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.68,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:19.890Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.32,0.68,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":101,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.68,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"180 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"68% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.7/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0570","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":15,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.74,"clarityScore":2.78,"evidenceConfidence":0.39,"clarityConfidence":0.76,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:20.129Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.32,0.45,0.17],"clarity":[0.03,0.03,0.09,0.85]}},"durationMs":87,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0571","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"weather","evidence":"partial","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.18,"evidenceScore":1.73,"clarityScore":2.59,"evidenceConfidence":0.52,"clarityConfidence":0.58,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:20.365Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.36,0.53,0.1],"clarity":[0.09,0.02,0.11,0.78]}},"durationMs":84,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0572","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.83,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.83,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:20.681Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.17,0.83,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":189,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"Notification was at least 14 days before departure.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Notification below 14 days reopens the notice and rerouting assessment.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0573","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.68,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.68,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:20.946Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.32,0.68,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":87,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":300,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €600; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €300.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0574","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":8,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.64,"evidenceScore":2.47,"clarityScore":2.77,"evidenceConfidence":0.47,"clarityConfidence":0.78,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:21.182Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.16,0.18,0.65],"clarity":[0.06,0.01,0.02,0.91]}},"durationMs":85,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0575","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"weather","evidence":"partial","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.43,"evidenceScore":2.01,"clarityScore":2.92,"evidenceConfidence":0.65,"clarityConfidence":0.93,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:21.419Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.17,0.65,0.18],"clarity":[0,0,0.07,0.93]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"The factual judgment does not meet the configured automation threshold.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0.5700000000000001,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"0 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"43% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"57% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 2.0/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Judgment strength must reach 90%, or the relevant risk threshold must be lowered.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0576","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.7,"clarityScore":2.98,"evidenceConfidence":0.32,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:21.652Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.09,0.31,0.41000000000000003,0.19],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.32,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"180 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"32% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.7/3, clarity 3.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0577","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.68,"evidenceScore":2.49,"clarityScore":2.82,"evidenceConfidence":0.49,"clarityConfidence":0.81,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:21.886Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.15,0.18,0.66],"clarity":[0.05,0.01,0.02,0.92]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":250,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €250; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €250.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0578","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.91,"clarityScore":2.88,"evidenceConfidence":0.44,"clarityConfidence":0.89,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:22.125Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.04,0.24,0.48,0.24],"clarity":[0,0.01,0.09,0.9]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.44,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"44% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.9/3, clarity 2.9/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0579","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":240,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.81,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.81,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:22.457Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.19,0.81,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":181,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.81,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"81% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.8/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0580","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.03,"clarityScore":0.58,"evidenceConfidence":0.96,"clarityConfidence":0.44,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:22.803Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.96,0.03,0],"clarity":[0.72,0.08,0.12,0.08]}},"durationMs":192,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0581","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":360,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.42,"clarityScore":0.13,"evidenceConfidence":0.58,"clarityConfidence":0.88,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:23.128Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.58,0.42,0,0],"clarity":[0.88,0.12,0,0]}},"durationMs":169,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":200,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €200.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0582","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":240,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":240,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.87,"clarityScore":2.76,"evidenceConfidence":0.41,"clarityConfidence":0.76,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:23.360Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.26,0.46,0.23],"clarity":[0.03,0.03,0.09,0.85]}},"durationMs":81,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":250,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0583","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":121,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.27,"evidenceScore":1.11,"clarityScore":1.41,"evidenceConfidence":0.87,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:23.597Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.9,0.06,0.03],"clarity":[0.48,0.01,0.13,0.38]}},"durationMs":83,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0584","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.76,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.76,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:23.856Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.24,0.76,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":109,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0585","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":119,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.82,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.82,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:24.108Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.18,0.8200000000000001,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":95,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"119 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 119 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0586","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":6,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.46,"evidenceScore":1.11,"clarityScore":1.75,"evidenceConfidence":0.89,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:24.358Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.92,0.05,0.03],"clarity":[0.35,0.01,0.18,0.46]}},"durationMs":97,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"6 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"46% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"0% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.1/3, clarity 1.8/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0587","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.86,"clarityScore":2.86,"evidenceConfidence":0.41,"clarityConfidence":0.87,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:24.622Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.06,0.25,0.47,0.22],"clarity":[0,0.02,0.09,0.89]}},"durationMs":111,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0588","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.68,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.68,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:24.851Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.32,0.68,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":76,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.68,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"239 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"68% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.7/3, clarity 0.0/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0589","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":180,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":59,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.22,"clarityScore":0.09,"evidenceConfidence":0.79,"clarityConfidence":0.92,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:25.117Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.79,0.21,0,0],"clarity":[0.92,0.08,0,0]}},"durationMs":115,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.79,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"13 days notice; no notice/rerouting exemption applies.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"79% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 0.2/3, clarity 0.1/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0590","origin":"New York","destination":"Dubai","originEU":false,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":179,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.35,"clarityScore":0.15,"evidenceConfidence":0.65,"clarityConfidence":0.85,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:25.358Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.65,0.35,0,0],"clarity":[0.85,0.15,0,0]}},"durationMs":86,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0591","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":181,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.79,"clarityScore":0.02,"evidenceConfidence":0.79,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:25.602Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.21,0.79,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":87,"decision":{"outcome":"APPROVE","reason":"Involuntary overbooking supports compensation in this model.","amount":400,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Involuntary denied boarding","detail":"Overbooking; passenger checked in on time with valid documents. Extraordinary circumstances are not used as an exemption here.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 7","label":"Compensation bracket","detail":"Base €400; rerouting reduction, if applicable, gives €400.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"A disputed or voluntary boarding refusal moves the case to review.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":true}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0592","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":239,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":60,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"crew","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.36,"clarityScore":2.68,"evidenceConfidence":0.5,"clarityConfidence":0.69,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:25.836Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.07,0.51,0.41,0.01],"clarity":[0,0,0.31,0.69]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.5,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"241 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"1% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"50% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.4/3, clarity 2.7/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0593","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":120,"noticeDays":13.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"weather","evidence":"complete","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.63,"evidenceScore":2.46,"clarityScore":2.71,"evidenceConfidence":0.46,"clarityConfidence":0.71,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:26.074Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.01,0.16,0.19,0.64],"clarity":[0.08,0.01,0.03,0.88]}},"durationMs":85,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0594","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Dubai","originEU":true,"destinationEU":false,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":6.9,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":90,"rerouteArrivalDelay":120,"cause":"mixed","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline cites severe weather, but the passenger has a message reporting a technical fault. Other flights departed. No airport closure notice or maintenance log is available; the primary cause and reasonable measures remain disputed.","boardingReason":"unknown","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":0.81,"clarityScore":0.01,"evidenceConfidence":0.81,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:26.311Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.19,0.81,0,0],"clarity":[0.99,0.01,0,0]}},"durationMs":85,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"179 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 179 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0595","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":5200,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":119,"rerouteArrivalDelay":239,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.01,"clarityScore":0.58,"evidenceConfidence":0.96,"clarityConfidence":0.43,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:26.576Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.02,0.96,0.02,0],"clarity":[0.72,0.09,0.09,0.1]}},"durationMs":113,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0596","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":179,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"safety","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.81,"clarityScore":2.81,"evidenceConfidence":0.4,"clarityConfidence":0.81,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:26.827Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.05,0.29,0.45,0.21],"clarity":[0.02,0.02,0.09,0.87]}},"durationMs":97,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Boarding grounds need individual assessment.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 4","label":"Boarding grounds","detail":"Only involuntary overbooking with valid documents and timely check-in is modeled.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Boarding grounds need separate assessment; care is not determined here.","counterfactual":"Establish involuntary overbooking and valid travel documents.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0597","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3501,"event":"cancellation","arrivalDelay":181,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":7,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"weather","evidence":"conflicting","narrative":"An official airport notice confirms all runways closed during the flight window due to a severe storm. The flight was directly affected. Records show the airline explored alternative airports and all reasonable rerouting options without success.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.42,"evidenceScore":1.1,"clarityScore":1.62,"evidenceConfidence":0.89,"clarityConfidence":0,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:27.055Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0,0.92,0.05,0.03],"clarity":[0.39,0.01,0.18,0.42]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","amount":0,"baseAmount":600,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"ART. 5(1)(c)","label":"Notice & rerouting","detail":"7–14 days notice; replacement departs ≤2 hours early and arrives <4 hours late.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Care while awaiting earliest rerouting; reimbursement or rerouting assessed separately. Compensation denial does not remove care.","counterfactual":"Crossing the departure or arrival rerouting limit reopens compensation eligibility.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0598","origin":"Barcelona","destination":"Berlin","originEU":true,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":3500,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":239,"departureDelay":300,"noticeDays":13,"rerouting":false,"rerouteDepartureEarly":120,"rerouteArrivalDelay":241,"cause":"maintenance","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The maintenance log identifies a worn hydraulic component during routine inspection. A replacement part was available at the base. The airline attributed the disruption to this ordinary technical fault.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.02,"evidenceScore":1.53,"clarityScore":2.38,"evidenceConfidence":0.51,"clarityConfidence":0.54,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:27.287Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.02,0.44,0.53,0.01],"clarity":[0,0.04,0.54,0.42]}},"durationMs":77,"decision":{"outcome":"REVIEW","reason":"Evidence is incomplete or contradictory. A human should resolve the facts.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":0.51,"threshold":0.9,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Departure from an EU airport, regardless of carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"239 minutes meets the 180-minute threshold.","state":"pass","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"},{"id":"ART. 5(3)","label":"Extraordinary circumstances","detail":"2% probability of an external, unavoidable cause with reasonable measures taken. Bounded Jev factual assessment.","state":"review","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"GATE v1","label":"Automation confidence","detail":"51% conservative judgment strength; 90% approval threshold. Evidence 1.5/3, clarity 2.4/3.","state":"review","source":"https://github.com/ankitkapooor/exception-engine/blob/main/docs/methodology.md"}],"assistance":"Departure-wait threshold met: meals and communications; accommodation if an overnight stay is necessary. At ≥5 hours, a reimbursement option may apply.","counterfactual":"Provide consistent evidence and a supported account of the cause.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":null}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0599","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":false,"distanceKm":1501,"event":"denied_boarding","arrivalDelay":241,"departureDelay":180,"noticeDays":14,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":61,"rerouteArrivalDelay":180,"cause":"unknown","evidence":"partial","narrative":"The passenger reports a disruption. The airline states operational reasons without supporting documents. The actual cause and mitigation measures are unknown.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":0.38,"clarityScore":0.12,"evidenceConfidence":0.62,"clarityConfidence":0.88,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:27.520Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.62,0.38,0,0],"clarity":[0.88,0.12,0,0]}},"durationMs":78,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Journey falls outside the modeled EU261 coverage.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Non-EU departure without a qualifying EU-carrier arrival.","state":"fail","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"}],"assistance":"Outside this simulation’s EU261 scope; other rights may apply.","counterfactual":"An EU departure, or an EU arrival on an EU carrier, changes coverage.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}},{"case":{"id":"EE-0600","origin":"New York","destination":"Berlin","originEU":false,"destinationEU":true,"euCarrier":true,"distanceKm":3499,"event":"delay","arrivalDelay":119,"departureDelay":179,"noticeDays":0,"rerouting":true,"rerouteDepartureEarly":121,"rerouteArrivalDelay":119,"cause":"crew","evidence":"complete","narrative":"The airline operations report confirms that a predictable crew scheduling error left the flight without a legal crew. No external incident was involved. The airline failed to activate an available reserve crew.","boardingReason":"overbooking","specialCase":false},"judgment":{"extraordinaryProbability":0.01,"evidenceScore":1.65,"clarityScore":2.99,"evidenceConfidence":0.3,"clarityConfidence":0.99,"mode":"live","model":"jev-1.14.0","questionVersion":"facts-v1","timestamp":"2026-10-25T10:34:27.755Z","distributions":{"evidence":[0.1,0.32,0.4,0.18],"clarity":[0,0,0.01,0.99]}},"durationMs":82,"decision":{"outcome":"DENY","reason":"Arrival delay is below three hours.","amount":0,"baseAmount":400,"confidence":1,"threshold":0.98,"rules":[{"id":"ART. 3","label":"Journey coverage","detail":"Arrival in the EU on an EU carrier.","state":"pass","source":"https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2004/261/oj/eng"},{"id":"3-HOUR RULE","label":"Arrival delay","detail":"119 minutes is below the 180-minute threshold.","state":"fail","source":"https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-rights/air/"}],"assistance":"Care waiting-time threshold is 180 minutes of departure delay; it is not met in this case.","counterfactual":"Increase arrival delay from 119 to 180 minutes to cross the timing boundary.","policyVersion":"EU261-lab/1.0.0","eligible":false}}]}
